36 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
I have a friend who served his mission in Mongolia. It was a no contact mission where he could only teach people who came to him. That was 7 years ago though. |
There is a China- Hong Kong Mission, and also a China-Taiwan Mission. |
Matt W., I should probably spread more rumors by saying this was for a total of four missionaries for mainland China, the calls were for 3 years, and were extended via personal phone calls with President Hinckley. |
Are we talking about full-time couples or full-time younger elders/sisters? |
One of the founding rumors that created the “Cynic” part of me was that one. It’s a constant, it’s not true. I have a feeling that this would be trumpeted with a lot more fanfare if it really happened. Trust me…we need an LDS version of Snopes.com. It would save me from spending 3 days in the Chicago Tribune’s archives trying (and succeeding) at disproving the “Jaredite Barges found at the Bottom of Lake Superior” myth. (The ‘barges’ were experimental fuel tanks from WWII) |
This urban legend is in the LDS World list of Mormon Internet hoaxes and urban legends (now housed on the SHIELDS web site). |
Wow, if this is a rumor, it sure travels fast. I heard the same thing last Sunday in my ward in Las Vegas about missionaries being called to 3 years missions in China. |
I would like to take this opportunity to put to rest all rumours and state plainly that the Three Nephites and John the Beloved are the four called to China to serve Full-time missions there for the next three years. They will not be reporting to the MTC, but will be traveling directly to China. Thank you. |
I figure anything I hear at church as a rumor is garbage unless I see it in the Church News or some other credible source. Then I don’t waste anytime thinking or worrying about it. Thanks for the clarification President Hinckley – boy MM has come a long ways… |
Mike Parker, That link pretty much covers it. I’ll update the main article. Thanks! |
Matt W., I should probably add that I was in the MTC when the first missionaries were called to Mongolia. They went around the Russian districts and pulled out the Elders that were learning the language the best and gave them a new calling. Then a bunch of the other missionaries getting sent to Russia got reassigned to Spain and Chile. |
I heard the same thing (four missionaries called to serve in mainland China for three-year missions) from a friend who heard it from some random guy standing in line next to her waiting to get into the First Presidency Christmas Devotional. I decided if I tried to tell her it was likely an urban legend, I couldn’t do it without be really snotty (I was in a bad mood), so I remained silent and changed the subject. So, yeah, I’ve heard it, but I don’t buy it. |
We had a missionary from Mongolia here a few years ago. She was from the capital city and was converted there. Her parents were also LDS. There are many devout LDS people who are teaching English in China. Many older couples who have already been on missions. I think that’s part of it, as well. |
Ok, so the Hong Kong mission does have missionaries which interact with the rest of China. I am not sure to what extent, but I know a Senior Couple who served as medical missionaries there during the whole “plague” thing a few years back. It was really scary amazing stuff. |
The country of Mongolia is not a part of China. It used to be called “Outer Mongolia.” There is a region or province called “Inner Mongolia” which is in the country of China proper. The languages spoken in Mongolia and Inner Mongolia are similar, but not the same. (Outer) Mongolia, the country, used to be part of the Russian/Soviet sphere of influence, and all the professional/technical people used to be Russians, and Russian was the secondary language of the country, after Mongolian. The Russians actually forced the Mongolians to change their alphabet for the Mongolian language from the Mongolian alphabet to the cyrillic alphabet. And the Mongolian Book of Mormon today is in the cyrillic script or alphabet. That’s probably why the first missionaries going to Mongolia were pulled from those previously called to Russia. Today, there is still more Russian influence there than Chinese. The above was explained to me by an Mongolian investigator. |
I heard an identical rumor back in 1999. It’s been around for a while. Back in February 2005, a BYU folklore professor mentioned the rumor in a Daily Herald story: “What’s idle speculation becomes gospel truth,” [Eric] Eliason said. “Most of the time rumors like this are harmless, sometimes they can damage, and sometimes they can pass on information that’s actually accurate.” |
I heard an identical rumor back in 1999. It’s been around for a while. In February 2005, a BYU professor of folklore mentioned the China rumor in a Daily Herald story concerning rumors about a missing Utah girl: “‘What’s idle speculation becomes gospel truth,’ [Eric] Eliason said. ‘Most of the time rumors like this are harmless, sometimes they can damage, and sometimes they can pass on information that’s actually accurate.’ For example, he said a story recently spread through LDS Church circles that a missionary had been called to serve a three-year mission to China. As the rumor snowballed, the Chinese government contacted church officials in Salt Lake City about the information. Church officials then had to set the record straight about the inaccuracy of the information. ‘It didn’t actually help the church’s chances of getting into China,’ Eliason said.” |
Funny you should write about such a rumor. I seem to remember hearing that same thing hear recently. I don’t remember where I heard it. I once heard that since the church had missionaries in Hong Kong that when it reverted back to control under mainland China that the Chinese government would be required (by law)to accept any religion that was in Hong Kong. I guess that one was false too? |
augh! our bishop’s wife shared this story in relief society the sunday after thanksgiving. she stated that they were at her friend’s house, where her friend opened his mission call in front of all of the family. the letter listed a phone number instead of the mission and when he called, he was placed on hold before being connected with the prophet and being asked to serve a “special” three-year mission in mainland china. it didn’t click for me until after church and i wasn’t sure how to let her know that *i* knew. she didn’t present it as hearsay, but as though she were there when it all happened. |
This rumor has been going around for YEARS. I heard it five years ago. |
I was just going to repeat what Sue said, but I remember the rumor 9-10 years ago….in fact the same person who swore that Steve Martin was LDS also claimed that her cousin’s friend was called to a 3 year mission in China. |
Wait a minute! You mean Steve Martin isn’t Mormon?! All kidding aside isn’t it interesting how people hold on to these (and others) Mormon urban legends? |
At least we can take comfort and solace in knowing the Ricky Schroder is a mormon….. |
This week’s Church News contains this item: “A rumor has been circulating that select members are being called on missions to China. The rumor claims that someone in a relative’s ward, or in a friend’s ward, received a letter extending a mission call but the field of service was left blank. According to the rumor, the individual was instructed to call a phone number and then was ‘patched through to President Gordon B. Hinckley,’ who then asked if the prospective missionary would be willing to serve a three-year mission to mainland China, the first year consisting only of humanitarian service. The Church News had been advised that this rumor has no foundation. No such mission calls have been extended.” |
I was actaully talking to my father-in-law about this very rumor just this weekend. A visitor in my Ward stood up in Priesthood and said the call cam to someone in his family’s Ward. My father-in-law smiled at the story because 2 years ago, he was in the Stake Presidency in Prescott, AZ. Elder Holland came to their Stake and was talking in a meeting about false rumors, and gave this exact story. |
Jared P., What I don’t understand is the need to outright lie about it. Why would your visitor feel the need to claim that it happened in his ward? Is he just really out of touch with his own ward or does adding that detail make the story sound more authentic? Weird. |
My best friend served his mission in Singapore, Mandarin Chinese speaking… someone in his stake high council or something knew this, and knew how much he loved the language and the culture… I guess the man had a nephew that received a mission call that was to mainland china for 3 years. 3 months in the mtc, then 9 months in the field learning the different dialects of mandarin(there are many, such as shanghainese)and doing service and what not… and then 2 years proselyting. And he was so excited to tell my friend… I guess this isn’t a very good source considering, I heard from my friend that this person in his stake has a nephew that received this “call” to mainland china… but my friend seems to believe it, and I just can’t let myself think that this man would lie about such things… maybe I am just hoping… but it really is believable… we have members in mainland china… I’ve heard of members in Tianjin, Beijing, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, & Shanghai… I have a friend that served his mission in Hong Kong China (not mainland china) and said that they would teach and convert people and they would go home to mainland china and teach their family and bring them to Hong Kong to get baptized. The church is growing in China even without missionaries… we’ve even had many missionaries come from mainland china and serve through out the world… and one thing that really makes it believable to me is certain events that are about to take place in China… 2008… Summer Olympics… LDS missionaries are known to take time from their proselyting and volunteer for the Olympics, I’ve heard of it since the summer Olympics in Sydney… I’m not sure exactly if it is true… but i’m also not sure it’s not… I plan on trying to come in contact with this man, and maybe even his nephew… I’ll let you all know if I find anything out… |
Dear Sir, |
Dear Sir, |
Dear Sir, Thanks a lot. Lenny |
I live in Guangzhou, just ran across this thread and there are no missionaries in my part of town, nor were there any in Beijing when I lived there a few years ago. Its hard enough to get any Chinese church materials into this country let alone enough to preach with. The church here is very interested in following the governments rules and regulations so one day when China does open there will not be any pre-existing issues. I really doubt there is any under the table “official” missionary work going on over here. Its just too risky for the church’s future status here, patients is a virtue. Anyhow, the church will one day be huge in China. People who find out I go to church and teach and learn about God are very interested. My favorite response is to tell them sorry your government will not let you learn (since they always say bad stuff about the US government its a nice change). These people are hungry for the truth! Their time will come soon, I’m sure of it. This country is changing at such a rapid pace it will only be a matter of a few years before it is open. |
Every big city in China has an LDS branch. Some range from 10 members to close to 800 in Beijing. There are also some small local branches that non-chinese national members are not allowed to attend. The Chinese governemnt allows the locals to worship as long as there are no non-Chinese nationals present. |
Hi, |
[...] LDS Missionaries called to China – Not yet. Read more about this rumor at the link above. [...] |
Hello fellow lds: We (3 of us) are planning to explore Guangzhou end of August 2011. Can anyone suggest where to stay right in the city of Guangzhou where it is safe and reasonable? Where are the LDS meet in city of Guangzhou? Thank you.! Ann F. B. |
These same types of rumors went around the Church 20+ years ago when missionaries actually first started getting called to Russia and the former Soviet Union. (Not saying missionaries are actually being called to China . . . just setting up the background for this story.) I was in the MTC preparing for a mission to Taiwan (Mandarin Speaking) when Elder Boyd K. Packer came to speak to the missionaries. As part of his talk, he opened up the floor for questions and answers. One missionary stood and asked, “I have heard of missionaries being called to Russia just receiving a call with a phone number and then they talk directly to a member of the First Presidency to receive their call. Is this true?” I still remember Elder Packer’s response. “My boy, all mission calls are issued in the exact same manner. Do you really believe that a missionary called to serve in Russia is any more important to the Lord’s work than someone called to another mission? I don’t. Next question.” I imagine that when the Church begins to send missionaries to China, they will receive their calls in the regular fashion, they will be for a regular length of time and we would likely hear the announcement of a newly formed mission as published in the Church News. |