30 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
On my mission I sometimes felt compelled to invoke a blessing on my food, especially the time when all stores were closed and all I had to eat was bug infested rice. Of course, I’m sure the bugs were rich in nutrients; a blessing in disguise, perhaps? |
I had a companion who looked at the dinner we were being served and made a sarcastic comment (in English) that the food needed “to be blessed twice.” What he didn’t realize was that the lady’s niece, who was sitting at the table with us, spoke perfect English. A few months later the same companion came downstairs and overheard me speaking in English with this same niece. His jaw dropped: “You speak English?!?!” She said, “Yes.” “Why didn’t you ever let me know you spoke English previously?” “Well Mr.-We-Have-to-Bless-the-food-twice” … He turned really red and I had a good laugh. |
Giving thanks for food i likely the best rationale; but, is it really going to hurt to likewise ask a blessing? |
Good point, Guy. I call that the “insurance” argument: If it’s not inherently bad to bless the food, why not, just in case? I think it may be the best argument for blessing the food, but doesn’t it kind of highlight the pointlessness of it? Why not extend blessings for other natural things, like blessing my lungs to inhale and exhale air (just in case, mind you) or my blood cells to travel safely through my body (again, just in case)? Sure, there are circumstances where those blessings might be appropriate, but usually not. Isn’t it better to avoid risking the vain repetition? |
We live in an age when food is now so highly processed it is no longer food. I think we need all the help we can get. |
With the scares that have arisen in the U.S. with food poisoning (peanut butter, spinach, etc.) and food sanitation (or the lack of food sanitation), you might not be able to take it for granted that food is safe. So maybe that blessing on the food is necessary after all. |
With my health problems, my prayer for the food to strengthen me is quite sincere. We’re weird, we’re totally inconsistent with personal prayers, but we never eat without thanking God for our bounty and asking His blessing. It’s one of the things I treasure about Bill, the humility of his bowed head over his oatmeal. We never pray in restarants, though. However you spell it. |
When I bless my food, I always utilize one of the standard formulae, but I don’t mean it literally. What I’m really asking for is that the food not trigger any very fatal type of food allergy. I also head into the body of all my prayers with the standard primary-aged beginning, “We thank Thee for this nice day” — even the prayers I’m saying to bless the food. This is no more of a vane repetition than the formula that I use to begin the prayer; viz., “Dear Heavenly Father.” Come to think of it, I’m going to have to differ with Jesus over this whole “vain repetitions” thing. I don’t think that his aversion to them is justified. Vain repetitions work quite well, like a security blanket almost. And isn’t prayer supposed to be a source of comfort anyway? |
I also always felt stupid when asking for the double-fudge ice cream sundae to “nourish and strengthen,” so I stopped. But people noticed and sometimes would ask me to say another one since I “forgot” or it would start a discussion akin to the one going on with this thread. So now, when asked to bless the refreshments these days I offer a sincere thanks for the food and then ask God to “bless it.” Amen. That seemed to stop it. |
Maybe you could say, “thank you for this yummy dessert. Please bless that we won’t gain an ounce and will enjoy every bite.” Or, thank you that we can afford this yummy dessert. please bless that the saints in Africa eat as well as we are eating now. I’m really going to do this. If I ever get asked to pray again in public. |
Yeah, the vain repetition thing seems always to be present; but, I think that’s just a reflection of probably how lazy I am when I attempt to communicate with Deity, rather than it actually being pointless to ask a blessing on say food, or as you point out, lungs or even blood cells. I’m grateful those things seem to work automatically, without the need to ask each day. And, from the finite mortal perspective, perhaps it does seem pointless; but, I’m coming more and more to trust less and less, my own finite mortal perspective in many things. |
anne, I think they’ve got your number, so I doubt you’ll get the chance. |
“Come to think of it, I’m going to have to differ with Jesus over this whole “vain repetitions†thing. I don’t think that his aversion to them is justified. Vain repetitions work quite well, like a security blanket almost. And isn’t prayer supposed to be a source of comfort anyway?” Sorry, DKL, you don’t disagree with Jesus on this one; you disagree with the KJV translators. A much better translation would be ‘empty phrases.’ I think we can all agree that insincere prayers are bad. |
OK, Julie. I’ll concede that Jesus was right — but just this once! |
I just thank God and ask him to “bless the food.” He can bless it anyway he likes. I think that it fits in line with the idea that we need to be thanking him constantly for everything, and being humble enough to petition him for strength to make it through each day and do his will. Asking for his “blessing” on the very food we need to survive is acknowledging him and helps us be humble. |
Have you ever heard of Dr. Masaru Emoto’s Messages from Water? He claims that prayer actually changes the make-up of water making it more pleasing (well at least he said the water crystalized more beautifully). I think most scientists call him a quack, but it is an interesting thought. |
When we were little, my sister couldn’t say “nourish and strengthen.” She said “nerkthen” instead. It became a family tradition, and we still say “nerkthen.” I’ll take our vain repetition over your sincerety any day. |
It might be that the object of the blessing is misplaced. In other words, maybe it’s better to bless ourselves rather than our food. If the purpose of blessing the food is for health– e.g., DKL wants to avoid a fatal food allergy– maybe it makes more sense to ask for a blessing on myself to be healthy, rather than blessing my food. JKS brings up an important related point: God is going to bless the food anyway He likes. Clearly, there are times when even well-blessed food causes food poisoning or other illness. So if one insists on blessing food, shouldn’t it always be accompanied with a caveat that goes something like, “Please bless this food [to not cause a fatal food allergy], but Thy will be done.” |
Tagore, that’s great! I’m going to change the formula I use when I bless food. Instead of saying, “Please bless this food so that it will be good and healthy for our bodies…” I’ll say, “please bless us that we’ll have no adverse reaction to the food sitting before us, if it be thy will…” I’m totally serious. |
DKL, now that’s the kind of blessing on the food I can endorse. Especially in the context of a church function when asked to bless the refreshments. “Please bless us that we will have no adverse or fatal reaction to the refreshments we are about to partake, but Thy will be done.” |
Everything we do during our mortal probation has both physical and spiritual consequences. Although we usually indulge in food for physical ramifications – I believe that blessing the food (that includes giving thanks, sanctifying and making a covenant or promise) has spiritual implications. jonathan |
I also agree with giving thanks for meals, which is why I’m intrigued by the little signs in temple cafeterias that say something like “this food has been blessed”–presumably to preclude people from “blessing” their food. |
I volunteered in the St. George Temple cafeteria for a year. What they do is, before it opens, they go into a little office and have a spiritual thought and a prayer which includes a blessing on the food. It’s an official thing. “They” being the cafeteria manager, temple president, and whoever’s there to work in the lunchroom that day. I don’t think they care whether or not people bless their food in the lunchroom before they eat. |
My wife hates it when I suggest we say the prayer after our meal so we know exactly how much of a blessing it needs. |
I totally agree that blessing the food so that it will “nourish and strengthen our bodies” is a vain repetition. However, giving thanks has a long and healthy tradition in Christianity and Judaism. And given the all the symbolism associated with meals (the sacrament and other covenant meals) and the fact that family dinners can be vital part of keeping our relationships strong, I think a blessing on the PEOPLE eating the food is a very appropriate thing to do. That’s what I’ve been doing for the past year or so: giving thanks for the food and then asking a blessing for the people I’m eating with. In ancient traditions, breaking bread or eating salt with someone was a covenant in and of itself that bound you together, then it makes sense that you’re reinforcing that bond everytime you eat again. And like I said, I think that’s a great thing to ask a blessing on. |
Just so I understand. It is generally the opinion on this forum that blessing something, for which there appears to be no physical revalence, is spiritually detrimental? jonathan |
Jonathan, I would just say it’s ironic to bless twinkies and 7up to strenthen and nourish our bodies. It’s like purposfully driving down the freeway the wrong way and asking HF to bless you with safety. |
I’m not sure there was any general consensus at all here except that DKL and I agreed on a good format for blessing the food. And I’d clarify that it’s not necessarily spiritually detrimental, but just pointless. Which I guess could be spiritually detrimental if it falls under the umbrella of what Christ called vain repetitions. But I didn’t get the sense that was a widely shared view. |
Julie, I agree with the idea of giving thanks for the food, but disagree with the notion of a blessing on the people eating the food. It seems a tad bit exclusionist. What if there are some in the room who are fasting, or simply prefer not to eat that meal? Will you not bless them because they are not eating the food? |
I dropped the “bless…nourish and strengthen” bit a long time ago, on the same vain repetition grounds. If I do bless the food I usually refer to it’s dubious origin (hence the blessing) while doing so–which always makes us laugh. For the sake of reverence I usually just give thanks. |