13 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
Any strong feelings about Val Kilmer as Joseph Smith? Though I suppose by the time Dutcher gets his funding lined up, Madmartigan will be too old. Alas. |
PDoE — I’m not sure whether your dismay is because Joseph Smith is being betrayed, or because Dean Cain is taking a part that doesn’t suit? In any case, I can share your giddiness over Alexander Siddig and the fun of seeing a favorite old friend in a good role. I just know I’m gonna regret confessing this, but I used to fly around to attend Star Trek cons. I even published a zine for a while, “ConTrails,” with transcriptions of stars’ speeches. Ooooo… there, I said it! |
I don’t know anything about that movie, why are you upset about it? Is it critical of the prophet? Ardis, the thought of you in Klingon ears makes me smile. I love when people are human. Slightly off topic, but I was at the Provo temple one time and the girl who played Eve was in the session with us. We all acted like we’d met a celebrity. Reverently, of course. And oh, I can’t think of his first name, but Brother Balaam made a pretty good Satan. Are we allowed to say that? |
…I used to fly around to attend Star Trek cons. I even published a zine for a while, “ConTrails,†with transcriptions of stars’ speeches. Ardis, I have always held you in high esteem, but my respect for you has now increased to the point that words fail me. |
Dean Cain–that just solidifies the fact that movie is going to stink it up. Have you seen Dean Cain act recently? He may be hot, but Keanu Reeves may win an acting award before Dean Cain. |
Annegb– September Dawn–A story set against the Mountain Meadows Massacre, the film is based upon the tragedy which occurred in Utah in 1857. A group of settlers, traveling on wagons, was murdered by the native Mormons. All together, about 140 souls of men, women and children, were taken. Amidst this, two young lovers-to-be, one a Mormon and the other one of the doomed settlers from Arkansas, develop a relationship in an atmosphere of suspicion and rancor. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0473700/ I think I’d rather watch Red Dawn again. Wolverines! |
Matt– I’ve never liked Val Kilmer. If he were to play Joseph Smith in an anti-Mormon movie I’d be annoyed that the movie was anti-Mormon at all. Kilmer in it would have no affect on me. Ardis– Cain’s casting in that part bothers me on two levels, the “say it ain’t so, Clark” level and the “but he doesn’t look ANYTHING like the character” level. I can be just as annoyed by regular, everyday incompetence as by deliberate malice (which it seems to me this movie is). |
Matt-Val Kilmer would be a good Joseph, but I am obsessed with the idea of Christian Bale playing JS. He would be perfect. Totally. Actually has anyone seen the movie Amazing Grace? I think the actor who plays William Pitt would also make a great Joseph. Sorry for the tangent. |
Val Kilmer? Do you guys say this because he did such a good job in The Saint? /sarcasm Not being in Utah anymore I don’t get the usual marketing of Mormon movies hitting the big screen, so I can’t comment on these latest movies (never even heard of them)… I also agree that Dean Cain would stink as Joseph Smith. He can’t even act in the show ‘Ripley’s: Believe it or Not’. I think Denzel Washington would play a better Smith…lol |
I love the idea of Christian Bale playing Joseph Smith! Right look, and he’s strong and soulful at the same time. He’d be perfect. |
Check the casting list – not only is Joseph Smith the Man of Steel, but he will KNEEL BEFORE BRIGHAM! |
I bring up Kilmer, of course, because he read Dutcher’s Joseph script and agreed to it, before the funding collapsed. He’s not bad, I think – his profile is perfect. |
Val Kilmer was horrible in the Saint, but have any of you watched his recent work? He was really, really good in the under-rated, hillarious Kiss Kiss Bang Bang. I think he would’ve been a decent choice to play Joseph Smith. Speaking of the casting for this movie? Trent Ford? He was “Frenchie” in season four of West Wing–his acting and accent was so bad he nearly brought down that season of the show–and its a huge ensemble cast. He was horrible. Then there’s that Mandy Moore movie “How to Deal” that I wish I could have those two hours back (in my defense I was knocked out on pain medication and immobile thanks to torn ligaments in my ankle). He sucked it up in that too. The only casting highlights in September Dawn is Angelie’s dad and Terence Stamp. |