37 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
Any Mormon worth his salt ought to recognize immediately that authorized Church videos are ALWAYS distributed from a big stack in the clerk’s office, handed out during Sunday School, Elders Quorum and Relief Society. Never on parked car windshields or shopping malls (unless it be in either Deseret Book or cheesy Christian-fundo-cartoon-kiosk which is only semi-approved). As for me and my house, we shall put our trust in Correlation. |
A couple of comments come to mind…by their fruits you shall know them and wolves in sheep’s clothing (referring to the cover). In this regard I am happy I live outside of Utah. No one around here except for the Mormons and a couple of my classmates (who want to go to the music and spoken word to listen to The Choir) know Conference is even happening. |
Seth: I had that thought too. I think a lot of people would. That’s just not the way the Church does things. But that they would even try it upsets me. Those who intend to deceive have still sinned, even if their intended victims don’t fall for it. |
While I have few problems with secular anti mormons this campaign infuriated me on a number of levels. They tried to keep it secret, going to the point of threatening to delete the blog of a secular anti who broke their story early. Their deception and the absolute idiocy of the stuff they present just burns. I’m no true believer, but their correlation between their 19th and 20th century interpretations of the Bible being used as ‘proof’ as to the falsehoods of the Book of Mormon is truly bizarre in it’s sheer hubris. Grrrrrrr… (by the way, the whole thing is now available online) |
I’d download it just to burn it and smash it but why give them the hits? Or waste my time and resources. Bah. :P |
cowards, the whole lot of them. |
Face it, they’re just out to bring us to a knowledge of “the truth”, and they know we’ll thank them for it once we’ve come to our senses. |
Post #2 Ben: Take a close look at the example of fruits Jesus gives when he says “by their fruits you shall know them”. Jesus then asks a question – “Do men gather grapes of thorns or figs of thistles?†Note that grapes do not grow on thorn bushes nor do figs grow on thistles. I understand this to mean that if we want grapes we go to a grape bush. If we want to learn of Catholics then go to a “Catholic bush†not a “Baptist bushâ€. Paul also stated that a “true Christian†will preach only the Gospel that they have received. The scriptures command Christians not to teach or publish any other Gospel – only the gospel they have received of G-d (including the Holy Ghost). So why is anyone other than the LDS teaching the LDS gospel? Answer: because they do not understand the prophesies of the scriptures concerning false teachers. jonathan m |
Jonathan |
“Can you clarify a little bit, or explain your last point in another way so I can comment. Thanks!” I’d like to think that he means, “If you want to know what Mormons believe, ask a Mormon.” Alas, I fear that’s not what he intended. |
I think he means “grapes taste better than figs.” |
[...] Heading over to bloggernacle, I quickly read the response at Mormon Mentality. [...] |
To learn about Math – seek out someone that is expert and successful at math. Do not seek out someone that is a failure at math or is against or anti to math. If someone would learn about LDS they should seek out someone that is expert and successful LDS and not someone that has failed at being LDS and is against LDS. Note also that thorns and thistles are intended to inflect pain and discomfort. Why should one try to get anything from someone that intends to inflect pain and discomfort. By this I understand that you should not learn about LDS or anything from someone that is trying to inflict judgmental pain concerning the subject. Note that one of the titles given Satan is the accuser and one of the titles given Christ is the advocate. Why would anyone that believes in Jesus Christ reject the concept of Christ like role of advocate and take upon them self the satanic role of accuser? jonathan m |
I wonder why some individuals are trying to destroy the Church thru black propaganda and they are quite fast in telling the whole world about their biases against the Church but fail miserably in standing for their own beliefs.I would like to make a proposition to all anti and ex-mormons.Assuming that the LDS Church is non-existent, what then is the “true Church” among the christian churches we have today (i.e. in terms of doctrinal soundness,church history,leadership and authority,purity and other related factors in establishing that theirs is really from God) ?Maybe you could choose from the ff: Catholics,Protestants,Evangelicals,Adventist,Jehovah’s Witnesses,Baptist,Church of Christ and Church of God. |
Although their efforts are likely misguided, I don’t understand the reaction. What does it matter that they put their words onto a DVD and distributed it? Why be bothered to be angry about it? I have much better things at which to be angry. |
If I get one of these on my doorstep I’ll be putting it in my microwave to watch the mini fireworks. YouTube here I come! |
Lpg, it’s not the fact that they put this thing on disk that is the problem, it’s the fact that they tried to disguise it as a church publication, or at lease something released by a member. It was a dishonest approach. That is the heart of the matter for me. They can make all the anti stuff they want and hand it out for free, but at least be honest about what you are trying to do. |
Ian-You are right,these people are dishonest and their only agenda is to destroy the Church.If they are really sincere and just wanted to spread their own “gospel” then they will not resort to these dirty tactics.I hope these people will be brave enough to show who their real identity and maybe share openly what they believe is true….It would be best,if they had shared their own “gospel” or belief system on DVD (also,I hope its free)… |
Ian – I watched it and don’t see how it’s disguised to come from the church. I think it’s pretty obviously not from the church. It doesn’t look anything like most of the official church publications. We know who produced it. |
SilverRain, it’s disguised. It resembles the CD’s the church puts in the Engsign from time to time. I live in Cedar City and it came in the mail today. I think somebody who wasn’t watching closely at first might not realize it’s not from the general authorities. lpg, I am incensed. Yesterday my VT companion and I went to Wal-Mart and spent $50 (in addition to money already spent) on diapers and clothing for newborn kits for babies in third world countries. My friends have spent hours making blankets for these babies. And these terrible people have spent millions of dollars and hours of their time denigrating my faith. I find it despicable. We would never do that to them. |
Jonathan M said if you want to know about mormonism to ask a mormon. I have found very few mormons who really know what they believe. They don’t bother to research the church’s history or even admit all the changes (if they even know about them) made in the BOM (over three thousand). The members are afraid to read anything except lds approved material. If mormonism is true, then a serious research effort will only prove what they believe. There must be some who are questioning the doctrine because appx 100,000 mormons are having their names removed from the church membership each year, and there are many others who just drift away. For those of you who believe that mormon’s would never do to other religions what these people have done, then why do they send out thousands of missionaries each year? |
Good question. |
[...] post at Millennial Star; Jeff Lindsay’s post at Mormanity; and, PDOE’s post at Mormon Mentality; I simply add one more voice in opposition to this type of bigoted anti-Mormon behavior by some of [...] |
Chanzie, We don’t picket the Billy Graham crusade and spend millions sending out CD’s saying their religion is false. We spend our millions on good things. |
No, lousy question. Disingenuous question. Our missionaries go out to bring people more truth. We seek to add to their faith. And we do it openly; our missionaries wear name tags that proclaim in large letters that they are from the “Church of JESUS CHRIST of Latter Day Saints.” (emphasis from the actual tags) I have gone out with the the missionaries many times to teach. We teach that “truth was lost” not “your leaders are child-abusing liars.” We teach investigators about what we believe. We do not teach them about their church– how could we? We ask them to pray and to learn for themselves whether our church is true. Missionaries are in no way comparable to these Anti-Mormon thieves. Yes I call them thieves for they seek to take away and do so by stealth and deception. And Chanzie, I would like to know just what you mean by “I have found very few mormons who really know what they believe.” That statement is presumptuous and offensive. Just how do YOU, who are evidently not LDS, define what we believe? And who are you to say what we believe? I am Mormon. I have been Mormon all my life. My family has been Mormon through six generations, including polygamy. More importantly, I have knelt down and asked God myself about the Book of Mormon. I know from a source no pundit, professor or scientist on earth can match about the truth of the Gospel. I know what I believe and you have absolutely no right to claim otherwise. |
And these terrible people have spent millions of dollars and hours of their time denigrating my faith. I find it despicable. We would never do that to them. Unless I’m mistaken, they believe that Mormon Doctrine in general is a denigration of their faith — their viewpoint is that we’ve taken the basic truths of the Bible and added all this other stuff to it from latter-day prophets and twisted it and perverted it so that it’s no longer Christian, and then we send thousands and thousands of missionaries out there to decieve people into believing a perversion of truth. They truly believe that they’re rescuing us from ourselves, and they’re trying to stop the spread of a perversion. At least, that’s my take on it. |
PDOE, Why are you so hostile and defensive? Why are you so sure I’m insincere about stating that many mormon’s do not know what they really believe? Just because you have been a mormon all your life is no guarantee that you know all the history and doctrine of the LDS church. It’s quite possible you believe everything you have been taught. Perhaps you have never delved into any of the darker side of your church’s history. Perhaps you are afraid to find that there are some very dark places in the life of Joseph Smith. And by the way, you may know what you believe, and it may not all be truth. That is a possibility for all of us. And why do you assume that I’m not a mormon? And why are you so absolutely positive that the “truth” was lost? This is just what you have been taught. Chanzie |
Chanzie, I’m sorry if I seemed hostile and defensive. I love God and I love His gospel. I tend to take it personally when I hear people smearing either of them but I’m trying to heed Elder Holland’s words this morning about the power of words. He reminded us that it is not what goes into the mouth that defiles it but what comes out of it. Chanzie, you made it fairly clear that you are not Mormon. You consistently used “they” in your post; obviously you consider LDS people to belong to a different group than you do. You also missed my point. I know what I believe and I know it is true because I have asked God. God Himself has confirmed His gospel to me and I’m rather inclined to take His word for it. |
There is one other thing, too, Chanzie. Mormons would consider it the worst of bad manners to send out missionaries and/or proselyte, say, during the Pope’s visit. We wouldn’t send out CD’s stating why the Pope is not a true religious leader prior to his appearance at a Catholic service. This whole deal is bad manners at the least. |
Dear PDOE and Anngb, Thank you for your responses. I am thankful you have put the anger, defensiveness and hostility behind. I grew up in a small mormon community and at that time mormon’s were very clear that they were not Christian’s that Christian’s were an abomination and only the mormon’s ,were right. I think that is still the prevailing belief, but now mormon’s want to be considered Christian. Your beliefs are not Christian. They are far from being Christian. I’m sorry if this offends you but it is the truth. You are momons and mormons you will stay unless you change a lot of your doctrinal stances. This is okay with me. I respect you and your right to believe as you choose. We are blessed to live in a country where we have that right. I deeply resent you portraying yourselves as Christians. You are mormons and mormons are not Christians. You may love God and try to serve Him by doing good works, and obey the WOW, and whatever else the current Prophet says you should believe. This is not what the true God requires. He requires that you place your faith and trust in Jesus Christ plus nothing. He states very clearly that good works will not save you…that good works are a result of your knowing Christ personally and your desire to love and serve Him. It’s a personal relationship. To even suggest that you can lose your salvation if you sin, confess it and do the same sin again you can never be forgiven is to negate the substitutionary and vicarious death of Jesus on the cross. He shed His precious sinless blood for you and me once for all. If it were not possible to be able to go to Him again and again for cleansing and forgiveness is to say His act of salvation was in vain. When He died on the cross, it was for all sin, past, present and future. Once you come into a personal relationship with Jesus, put your faith and trust in Him, and believe on and in Him, you are saved from sin. Sadly, we all posses that old sin nature and we live in a fallen world. We cannot stop sinning anymore that we can stop going to the bathroom. Only when we we die is the flesh is no longer subject to sin. We aren’t sinners because we sin; we sin because we are sinners. But we can become saved sinners, by God’s incredible gift of unmerited favor: Grace. You see, your belief that when Adam and Eve disobeyed God by eating the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, did not cause all people and the world to become fallen has everything to do with your understanding of salvation. I can’t change your minds about this, but you can search the scriptures and find out the truth for yourselves. You have the ability to see that early mormon leaders were wrong when they proclaimed that the entire Earth didn’t fall as a result of Adam and Eve sinning. We are born into sin and this curse is upon us until we receive the salvation so freely offered by Jesus. Our flesh is still sinful and even when we don’t want to sin, we do. The Apostle Paul said that he always did what he didn’t want to do and didn’t do what he wanted. “Who can deliver us from this body of sin and death,” he said. (Romans 7:15). I am very sorry this method of witnessing to mormons is so highly offensive to you. As those who appear in the dvd said, “We love mormons and we want them to come to saving knowledge of Christ.” We want you to have the truth about the lies of Joseph Smith and other lds leaders. You may think this is a way of showing hatred, but if we didn’t love you why would be spend all this money and risk your wrath by passing out these dvd’s in the hope that some of you might examine some of your more bizzare teachings. I personally didn’t have anything to do with this effort, but I pray it will reach those who are open to at least looking at some mormon practices and beliefs and checking them against sound Biblical doctrine. Jesus commanded us to go into all the world and preach the gospel (good news). Someday I have to stand before a HOLY GOD and explain why I didn’t obey His commandment to share the gospel with those who thought they already had the truth. I would rather incur your wrath than have Him look at me in disappointment . I am haunted by the thought that my mormon friends will wonder why, if I said I loved them, I didn’t make some effort or attempt to share the truth with them. I also want to share this truth with anyone else who hasn’t heard about or knows the God of the Bible. This will be my last post as I realize I am mostly just making you angrier and defensive and even hostile to checking out the truth for yourselves. However, I will be praying for you…I don’t mean that in a condescending way at all. I believe you do love God and want to serve and please Him. I just believe you have been deceived by the early leaders of your church and I want you to know the truth. I think it’s like you sending your missionaries out to share with us what you believe to be “more truth.” In Christian love, Chanzie |
Chanzie- Now i understand why you treat us that way because you have a distorted view of our basic beliefs. 24For he beholdeth himself, and goeth his way, and straightway forgetteth what manner of man he was. 25But whoso looketh into the perfect law of liberty, and continueth therein, he being not a forgetful hearer, but a doer of the work, this man shall be blessed in his deed. 26If any man among you seem to be religious, and bridleth not his tongue, but deceiveth his own heart, this man’s religion is vain. 27Pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this, To visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction, and to keep himself unspotted from the world”. There are quite a number of scriptural references that runs counter to the doctrine of these “born again” people With these, i am also beginning to feel inclined not to call these people christians because they preach a false doctrine.If i were a Catholic,i rather remain to be one because at least they believe in good works and has a claim that they hold the keys to the Kingdom of God (or Priesthood authority)thru the principle of Apostolic succession. I hope this will help you understand our sentiments…. |
As far as I’m concerned this all comes down to people treating other people like crap, principles completely aside. Mormons have treated this woman badly. That’s sad. This is between her and God and I actually am sort of the grace sort of person myself. Chanzie, I’m sorry that happened, it happens to all of us. People of all faiths behave in unChristian manner, when you’re surrounded by one faith, the bad sticks out. I’ve been treated like crap by people of every faith. By those standards I should be an atheist. On the other hand, I have dear friends of all faiths, well, except Islam. I’ve found that people of all faiths have some basically similar beliefs in the goodness of God and our duty to serve others. God’s going to work out the kinks in us all. |
Chanzie: I grew up in a small mormon community and at that time mormon’s were very clear that they were not Christian’s. Impossible. This “Mormons are Christian” thing isn’t some recent PR invention. Mormonism has never conceived of itself as anything other than a Christian church. Chanzie: I deeply resent you portraying yourselves as Christians. No serious argument can be based on the fact that you deeply resent something. The dispute about the role of grace alone vs. grace + works has been raging for centuries. Thanks to what Paul said and what James said, Christians of all denominations have been debating this something approaching an eternity. Furthermore, the argument about whether we require the atonement to expiate original sin or just for our own transgressions has been a point of contention for hundreds of years. It’s at the heart of the dispute over whether or not one baptizes babies: If you believe in original sin, then the infant needs baptism. If baptism is for remission of one’s own sins, then the infant does not need baptism. This is a pretty mainstream dispute, and the Mormon position is not a terribly unusual one. Don’t pretend that (a) these issues are a dividing line for determining who is and isn’t Christian, and (b) that a few quotations from the Bible can lay these issues to rest. If you don’t believe in our Mormon prophets, then you’ll have to concede that God doesn’t really care what side of the dispute we take up, because if he really cared, he’d have given us a clearer indication of the correct point of view. But if you keep up your current activities, you’ll likely find yourself damned for abusing the word of God to justify your attempts to Lord your morality over others. |
Oh, David, she’s not going to be damned any more than you or I are damned. |
Speak for yourself, annegb ;) |
#20 – annegb – I suppose I’ve never paid attention to the looks of the official CDs before. Even if it is disguised, anyone watching it would know immediately that it isn’t official – or even produced by LDS members. It’s not going to convince anyone who isn’t already (at least half) convinced. As a good thing – it might even lead some people to sincere examination of their beliefs, which can only deepen faith. I still don’t see the point to being upset about it. |
Chanzie
This is as much of a lie as are the defamatory DVD’s your groups promulgate. |