62 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
[...] BCC, in its own inimitable, yet humble way has T.O.T.A.L.G.C.T. Not to be outdone, DKL over at Mormon Mentality is also running an open thread. There should be some great insights on all of these great LDS [...] |
I’ve always found the song they sung for the opening hymn “Sweet Hour of Prayer” to be a little bit confusing. Why do we sing it so often when so few members have even prayed for an entire hour? |
What’s CDT? Central Deseret Time? |
First speaker, RGS, is talking about prayer. Maybe that’s the theme for this session. |
CDT = Central Daylight Time. But I like Central Deseret Time better. But if it were on Central Deseret Time, it would have started 15 minutes later. I always dislike the reading of celebrity mormon deaths. It strikes me as exclusionary and elitist. |
announcing deceased “prominent” members has always irked me. Still does. Why do they do that? |
I agree with you on that, cj douglass |
They should instead read a list of normal Mormons who died in extraordinary ways. |
LOL. That would be much better. |
Do Mormons die in extraordinary ways? |
Is it me, or are these talks shorter than usual? |
Does anybody know if the General Authorities select the topics of their talks themselves, or are they assigned from the First Presidency? |
Combine accidents and whatnot. |
Why do they do that? Could it be that most of us wouldn’t know that they have died unless they announced it? I like the celebrity death segment. |
I care about the “ordinary” deaths just as much as the “prominant” deaths. I would guess the majority of the church feels the same way. |
Jacob J, why focus on the dead Mormons? Why not focus on the resurrected ones? |
This is the first time that I’ve ever heard a GC speaker quote the Apocrypha. I feel so vindicated. I spoke in sacrament meeting once many years ago, and I told a fable from the Apocrypha to illustrate a point. Everyone told me that I was gutsy, and the rumor spread that I’d quoted the Koran. |
Wait, I think those times are MST (mountail) not CST (Central). I’m on central, and the conference didn’t start until 11:00 am here. You’re leading the flocks astray yet again, DKL. |
cj douglass, No, most people care more (demonstrably) about deaths of people they have heard of then the deaths of people they have not. Do you think news organizations should stop reporting the deaths of former US presidents until they devote time to telling us about every death in the country. Surely you are pulling my leg with this. |
I didn’t recognize one of the names announced today. My point is that most of the church probably didn’t recognize them either. I get your point though. |
pickle analogy? I like it! |
We are all cucumbers striving to become pickles…. ….. |
DKL #2 I always thought it should be changed to sweet three hours of prayer, lol. Prayer can be a broad term used to describe a church meeting, talk, sermon, etc. Many talks are ‘prayers’ to the members to do something. Often talks are ended by saying something to the effect of “I pray you may take these words into heart”, etc. I am guessing you were not being serious, but just in case those are some thoughts :) |
Stats analysis here, for those interested. |
[...] enjoy!!! Feel free to discuss at T&S, or at Mormon Mentality or [...] |
BTD, oops. Fixed the timezone thing. Thanks. If we’re supposed to be pickled, does that mean its OK to consume strong drink again? |
That’s an interesting analysis, John. Nice to see that baptisms per missionary are up again. |
Nice closing song. |
queno, |
When Elder Bednar was waxing nostalgic/philosophical about pickles, what kind of pickle were you picturing in your mind? Dill? Sweet? Bread and Butter? Relish? Gherkin? Kosher? |
…the Vlasic Stork kept entering my mind….CRUNCH! |
“Hour” is also often used to mean “time of.” When someone says “The hour is at hand,” they don’t mean that whatever’s happening is going to take an hour. So “sweet hour of prayer” just means “sweet time of prayer,” and it can’t be amended to say “time” ’cause that would ruin the scansion. :) |
Ben, perhaps if it were called “Sweet Three Hours of Prayer” more members would pray for an hour. |
I liked the parable of the pickle. It reminds me of Jesus’s parables in that it’s so simple and humble. So if the brine is the gospel, does anyone have any thoughts on what the dill, garlic and other herbs would represent? |
dill = the sacrament |
sisters = catty |
Parable of the Pickle. I like it too. |
I loved the talk on words by Elder Holland. For awhile I’ve thought that George Orwell’s essay on Politics and the English Language was my favorite essay on how words should (and should not) be used. I think I might have to add Elder Holland’s talk to make that a list of two important sources on the topic. |
Elder Bednar’s talk made me think of John Donne a bit … his ability to compare two seeming unlike things and develop insights from the comparison. |
Okay, sorry – three comments in a row … but during Elder Holland’s talk I thought it would be funny to have a post titled “How Elder Holland Slew the Snarkernacle.” |
Okay, I guess I’m on a roll here … but I just got home from watching the sessions at the chapel (no cable television here at my place) and have got different things on my mind. The Apocrypha book that Elder Holland quoted from is referred to as “The Wisdom of Ben Sira” or “The Wisdom of Yeshua ben Sira” or “Sirach” or “Ecclesiasticus.” There’s some good information on the book at wikipedia here. Here’s the actual quote. It’s found in the aforementioned book, chapter 28, verse 17:
There’s quite a number of verses here talking about the problems caused by the tongue. It actually looks like a chapter that is well worth reading. At least parts of it. I may have to start reading more of the Apocrypha. |
Connor, e.g. |
Did anyone else hear sirens in the background of the first talk of the second session? |
PDOE, I didn’t notice any … |
Huh. I had a bit of a shock. For a few minutes I heard what sounded like sirens in the background, then they stopped. A minute or so later the broadcast abruptly broke off. It restarted again shortly; it must have been computer error. But those few moments sure made me worry! I think there have been some computer issues this conference. During the first session this morning there was a warped, tinny echo. |
PDOE, it wasn’t just you. There’s some mention of these sirens over on the T&S thread as well. |
For as long as I can remember I have heard sirens at some point when GC is broadcast from the Tabernacle. It must be less sound-proof than the conference center. |
The parable of the pickle was nice, but a real parable, and the best kind, are those delivered without explanation. A parable is supposed to be left for the listener to decipher. This was certainly the way that Jesus did it….scholars believe that the explanations that follow some of the Biblical parables were added later by the apostles. It would have been interesting to see Elder Bednar just throw out the pickle parable and then let the listener chew on it. Pun intended. |
DKL, Think “his hour of need”, etc. |
Isn’t re-dedicating the old tabernacle a complete waste of time? What, maybe a corrupt construction worker entered in, so the spirit left the building, or something? O’well, they can add that to the list of pointless, time-consuming objects of adoration, like the temple ceremony. |
Bob, go play in the food processor. |
Someone re-dedicate this thread–it’s been defiled by Bob. |
I’m afraid the commenters will be just as hard-headed as they were before. |
My apologies…I turned on the TV thinking maybe there would be something prophetic…well, nice to see they’re spending all your tithing money, though. Good way to complement the God’s new mall across the street. |
Dear Heavenly Father, please bless Bob. Amen. |
I heard last week a quote, I am not sure who it is by, |
Closing Hymn, The Spirit of God. Wow. |
One thing I like about the pickle parable is that it can have broader appeal than just to Utah Mormons or American Mormons. I’ve eaten more home-preserved fruits and vegetables in the Middle East and especially in Central Asia than I ever have in the US. This story wouldn’t have been as difficult to translate in other languages as the stories you hear at the Christmas devotional. Go pickles! |
I tried hard to feel inspired by the process of making pickles. But it just didn’t drive home the meaning of our mortal probation to me. I mean, it’s a pickle for crying out loud. The whole part about pickles needing to be cleaned — it felt a little forced. It would have been a more effective parable if most of us made pickles for a living or something. Like a previous poster mentioned, if you have to explain it, it’s probably not the best parable. Of course, maybe I just don’t have ears to hear. |
I agree with you, Paul. The pickle parable seemed a bit to Monty Python for General Conference. |
Mark Butler: Think “his hour of needâ€, etc. Dude, “hour of need” obviously refers to the period of time in which something is needed, just like “winter of our discontent” refers to a specific season. If you get a call from one of your home teaching families in their hour of need, you’ve pretty much got 59 minutes to make it there and give ‘em a blessing. Otherwise, you’ve missed the opportunity, and in all likelihood you will have to wait another week. |
I liked the pickle parable but I can see why others might find it unusual. I think it worked for me because it was told in the context of his memories bottling pickles with his parents. I liked the way he spoke of cleaning, immersing, sealing … and then how he spoke about our need to go through a fundamental change. |