23 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
DkL as always I enjoy your posts. |
DKL, I’ve come to enjoy blogging here. I’m going to respond quite seriously to your post, though–no humor. I’ve always been a little disturbed by the “striking” miracles–loaves and fishes, healing the blind, etc. I love them, of course, and I believe in them. But for me, the greatest miracle has always been the way faith makes new creatures of us, enfolds us into Christ and Christ into us. The irony of your post (and I read your early draft–you have now left out the warning to your readers to not faint when they learn that you are considered a role model for the youth) is that you are yourself the miracle, wrought into a new creature through Christ. You’ve published elsewhere about your earlier aetheism and your change of heart. Not so many years ago, if you were driving somewhere fast on a Sunday, it would not have been to a store to buy bread for the sacrament. Maybe you would’ve bought something, but not bread–at least not for that purpose. Somewhere, your journey–even an unorthodox one like buying sacrament bread on the Sabbath–has become consecrated. I have seen miracles in my life (including some big ones which would qualify as “striking” and which I do not share capriciously.) Sometimes, the miracles have come BECAUSE I have been foolish and have gotten myself into situations which required some serious intervention. Other times, I have been an honored witness. I’m going to share one miracle I witnessed, simply because I want a record of it and I’ve never written it down. When Bruce and I moved into our neighborhood, the guy up the street was a grumpy steel worker with a 3-pack-a-day habit. He could lose his temper over dog poop. That was over twenty years ago. Things happened in his life which are not mine to tell, but they resulted in him returning to the Mormonism he had abandoned as a 16-year-old. He came back to church shyly, and finally offered a halting testimony of about three sentences. Within a year, my husband helped ordain him to the Melchizedek priesthood. (His wife and family had been active through all of this time.) Exactly one week after he was ordained to the priesthood, his house burned down. It was arson, and it had been well-planned. Propane tanks exploded, sending 70-foot flames into the air. I remember waking up and being aware that something was wrong–the sky was strangely red–and then hearing my neighbor knocking frantically on our front door to get us out, because our home was also threatened. An ambulance pulled up. My neighbor’s wife was in shock, and was put into the ambulance on a stretcher. Bruce and I could see into the ambulance’s back window from where we stood on the street. I saw my neighbor kneel beside his wife and put his hands on her head. I said to my husband, “Bruce, he’s giving her a blessing. He’s giving his wife the first blessing he’s ever given.” That man has now served as my bishop for six years. He has become eloquent, wise, and full of love. He is radiant. His testimonies now are considerably longer and more fluid. But he is an example in the flesh of God magnifying an offering, whether it’s an offering of fish and bread, or of a contrite heart yearning for redemption. |
I think Margaret, in a way, gets at your question, DKL. To what extent are miracles, as you assume, a function of our own faith? Can we _earn_ miracles by manifesting faith? Scripture says that faith can move mountains, but it also tells us that faith itself is a gift. Or perhaps miracles are a manifestation of God’s unmerited grace in our lives; something which we can be grateful for, but not expect? That’s hard to hear; we tend to think that if we are worthy of something we have somehow earned it. |
I’ve broken the sabbath (on one occasion) to purchase sacrament bread and I hated the fact that this was happening. However, there was some amusement in the eyes of the cashier that morning and we chatted a little. It was obvious to me that this cashier had seen a man in a suit and tie purchasing white bread on many-a-Sunday-morning and that by now she knew exactly what was going on. Without meaning to criticize DKL specifically (since I’ve been in the same boat) I think that this kind of thing is a sign of laxity. As stewards, we need to be almost paranoid sometimes. We should pre-imagine things that could go wrong and do what we can to prevent these things from happening. On the Sundays after I ended up purchasing bread, I would find myself bringing a loaf to church just in case. It didn’t matter to me whether or not someone had been assigned. I simply wasn’t willing to let that happen ever again. Of course that level of caution has disappeared now that I’m in a different ward and I have a calling that has no association whatsoever with the sacrament. |
Thanks for the story and thought provoking commentary – DKL. Margaret – I love the story. I have a similar one to that from my current ward. It is certainly faith promoting to see such examples of the Lord changing a person’s heart. I feel somewhat like you do, DLK, about miracles, in that I do not have faith that such miracles as the loaves and fishes will occur if there is not a need for them. For example, when I was in the Bishopric, I had to run to the store several times for bread. We talked about it as a Bishopric – particularly about the potential for us to have a miracle of the loaves and fishes. We decided that there was probably not the need for a miracle since a store was just down the street. To me, it seems that miracles should occur when there is a need combined with the faith… |
“Or perhaps miracles are a manifestation of God’s unmerited grace in our lives; something which we can be grateful for, but not expect?” I think this is right. Miracles are real, but they are also not ours to command and come without regard to worthiness. All I can do is be grateful when they happen and not too unhappy when they don’t. |
Margaret, don’t make me cry ona monday morning you jerk. DKL, The line between faith and foolishness for me is an economic line of cost/benefits analysis, as bad as that sounds. |
Are we absolutely sure that purchasing bread on Sunday morning is truly “breaking the Sabbath”? My understanding of the Sabbath is that there are guidelines with personal revelation filling in the cracks. I’m not saying that buying bread isn’t against the Sabbath for some, but can we make that into a blanket statement? I guess my Sabbath beliefs have evolved over time and have changed pretty dramatically since we’ve lived in NYC. We tend to not have our fridge/cupboards full of groceries (buying groceries here is a nightmare, especially in my neighborhood), so we’ll sometimes run to the cornerstore on a Sunday afternoon to pick up eggs (or whatever). Margaret, |
I think that the level of faith that is required for a miracle is the level of faith that allows one to know God’s will concerning the matter. As the scripture says, “Require not miracles, except I shall command you,…” DC 24:13. Before you say to the fishes and loaves to multiply, before you proclaim “rise up and walk” or “receive thy sight,” the Spirit will inform you or confirm to you if indeed it is Heavenly Father’s will for you to say those things. And the information that comes through the Holy Ghost in those instances will usually be along the lines of the instructions given to Oliver Cowdery, either a confirmation, a stupor of thought, or nothing. Or, as stated elsewhere in scriptures, the words you are to speak will be given you in the very hour, or very moment in which you speak. As Spencer Kimball wrote, faith precedes the miracle. Not just a “believing” kind of faith, but an active faith, that of doing. And the “doing” that is required is all we can possibly do. I am often amazed at the wonderful blessings and miracles that Heavenly Father pours out upon us, if we’ll only do the preparatory work needed to receive them. We have to turn our cup face up, not face down, in order to receive a blessing or miracle. If we want a big blessing/miracle, we won’t get it if we don’t hold out a big enough container to receive it. I think there are righteous ways of seeking blessings and miracles. One is to study the scriptures and modern church history to see what kinds of blessings, miracles, events, and actions Heavenly Father generally wants to bring about. And then prepare yourself for those, so if and when Heavenly Father wants something accomplished, you will be available, prepared, and willing to play the role he may have for you. I’ve often considered how unworthy I am to play the parts I’ve been called upon to perform, and wonder how it is that those assignments came to me. And the answer I seem to get most often is “No one else was willing and prepared to do that.” |
Bookslinger, I have had similar experiences to what you describe above. But I have also found myself unwittingly in the midst of a miracle without any preparation of my own, and certainly without any particularly worthiness, but simply because God was protecting me (or so I interpret it). One more quick story, then I’ll return to today’s tasks: During a summer years ago, I lived in one part of Guatemala and my dad lived in another. Some bad things happened and I needed to get to my dad. I knew the approximate area where he was, and (being spontaneous and foolhardy), I simply got on a bus and went to Guatemala City, a four-hour trip. Unfortunately, I didn’t know that the aldea where Dad was living was not reachable by bus. I knew what the closest city was and IMAGINED (falsely) that I could just walk a mile or so and find Dad. Night was already setting in, however, and I had no idea of bus schedules. I finally found a bus headed for Coban, which I knew was fairly close to my destination, and got on. A Guatemalan woman got on just after me and put her bags on the other side of the bus. She glanced at me and sat down by her bags. She looked at me again and then moved to the seat just in front of me. We started a conversation–a typical one. “So where are you from? Why are you in Guatemala?” Then out of the blue she asked, “Are you a Mormon?” I answered, “Si.” She smiled. “Yo tambien.” Now, was this a miracle or a UFO? Guatemala is about 98% Catholic. What are the odds that I would get on a bus with perhaps the only Mormon in the entire terminal (which is a huge terminal)? Now add this: She told me that she hadn’t planned on sitting by me; she had wanted some privacy. But something kept prodding her, and she knew that she and I needed to have a conversation. Now the kicker: It turns out that I would not have been able to get to where my dad was that night. It was many miles away from Coban. And (amazingly–my stupidity still floors me), I didn’t have enough money to get a hotel room. I would have been left at the bus terminal in Coban with no idea of how or where to proceed and no money to even buy a chuchito for breakfast. (I had talked to a lot of people at the Guat City terminal, and nobody had heard of the Aldea I was headed to.) As it turned out, this woman’s son happened to work at the aldea where Dad was. I spent the night at her home, she fed me a delicious supper, and the next morning her son took me to my dad. I’d call that a miracle, but it certainly was not earned. Please note that only professionals should attempt such an experiment. I did not realize that my decision to get to dad was tempting God to dispense His angels to help me–or not. I was just plain stupid. I’m afraid my younger life is pocked with other equally stupid acts, and I hope none of my children follows my example. Nonetheless, I am writing this some thirty years later, still alive. I’m acknowledging that miracles aren’t necessarily prepared for. I suspect that I have exhausted my guardian angel, who will probably wipe angelic sweat from his/her forehead and exhale a sigh of relief when I finally pass through the veil at the end of my mortal journey. |
Margaret, your comments #2 and #10 are so excellent they should be posts. Someone sign her up. That’s an order. :) |
Margaret, the willingness and preparation was on the part of the Guatemalan woman who followed the prompting to talk to you. She had developed the ability to hear and obey the voice of the Spirit. Knowing something of the Latin-American culture, I’m sure she considered it a great blessing and honor to be called upon by the Lord to offer you assistance in your journey. Therefore, you were the instrument of her blessing too. Had you had the means of getting your own hotel room, you would have insulted her and denied her her blessing had you refused her invitation to stay the night at her house. The Lord must have a soft spot for the young-and-stupid. Otherwise how could our missionaries have so much success at baptizing people? I also think it miraculous that many more of our missionaries don’t die through illness, accident, or violence. |
Margaret #10 – I second Danithew – what a great story! I think the point about unearned miracles is true – I have had experiences like that in my life as well. The beautiful thing is it always lets me know that God is watching over us and he actually knows who I am (a little peon amongst billions of his children). |
On the other hand, my brother once did not have enough bread, but blessed it anyway and it sufficed for the entire congregation. |
JA Benson, that’s a great story. I did buy 2 loaves of bread, so there is now one in the freezer. Margaret, you make a good point about where I’d be nowadays on Sundays. This past Sunday, I’m happy to report that I’d have probably been sleeping. For many years I worked 7 days a week, including Sundays. My office was downtown in Boston, and I took a lunch break one Sunday where I drove down Boylston Street (or maybe it was Newbury Street) looking for a tobacconist that was open to purchase the Nat Sherman cigarettes I smoked. I did find one, but I usually made it a practice to stock up on Saturday to avoid having to locate a tobacconist who kept Sunday hours. On the other hand, my wife laughs that my family gives her credit for every redeeming trait that they see in me. They are, undoubtedly correct, but she doesn’t want any part of it. It’s a double-edged sword: Taking credit for my progress over the years means taking blame for my frequent backsliding, and our marriage is a constant battle to keep me from eating my dinner over the sink. Eventually, she just shrugs and says, “Well, he cleans up nicely.” She also claims that I’d have made the same kind of progress into adulthood with or without her. And who knows but that I’d be in a very similar place (sans the frantic search for bread) without the church? It’s hard to say what changes are inevitable and which are contingent, or which are “real” and which are just veneer. There’s just no telling. One can say that it’s better to search for bread on the sabbath than for tobacco because it’s better to be Mormon. But I think that if you work out that line of reasoning, you’ll end up begging the question. That said, both of your comments are a heck of a lot better than my post. Really amazing stories. In the end, miracles don’t have to be earth shattering — just self-shattering in some sense. And the way you tell these stories communicates their profundity in a big way. I’m happy to have your comments, but you should be getting the idea that we’d love to have you blog here. |
DKL, If you had not brought the bread, the only result would be that someone at Church with enough responsibilities already would end up running home and getting some bread. |
Seth, then my response would have been, “It’s a miracle!” |
There was a British movie released in 1969, called Bedazzled starring Dudley Moore as a guy who sells his soul to the devil for seven wishes. He gets everything he asks for, but it goes awry when the devil upstages him, and gives him what he asks for, not what he really wanted. In the part where this ordinary-human-looking man claims to be the devil, Dudley asks him for some kind of sign to prove he has the power to grant wishes. When the devil asks what he wants, Dudley asks for the devil to make him an ice-lolly (popsicle). Just then, an ice-cream vendor wheels by, and the devil stops him, buys a popsicle, and gives it to Dudley. Dudley protests that it wasn’t a miracle, just an ordinary purchase, and the devil responds “You got what you asked for, so why are you complaining?” There are parts in it that mainstream christian denominations would find very irreverent, but most of the things being lampooned are points where LDS doctrine differs from mainstream denominations. One such gag is based on “God is everywhere at once” so the devil kicks Dudley Moore in the butt, and says “God was in your back pocket.” If you ever see it listed in your TV listings, it’s worth setting your TIVO or VCR to record. Or buy it if you see a used VHS of it for sale for a couple bucks. The memory of that popsicle gag has stayed with me. Our prayers are often answered through seemingly ordinary means. |
Bookslinger–that reminds me of a joke I heard as a child, where a guy unleashes a genie who grants him three wishes. For his first wish, the guy asks for a new car. Poof! He has a new car. For the second wish, the guy says, “I’ve always wanted to own a Dairy Queen.” Poof! The Dairy Queen appears. The genie says, “What next?” and the guy is stumped, because he now has everything he has ever wanted. “You’ve got to think of something,” says the genie. “Okay,” says the guy, “I guess–make me an ice cream sundae.” “As you wish,” says the genie. “Poof! You’re an ice cream sundae.” Btw, Bookslinger, I really liked your idea of the Guatemalan woman being the prepared one. I recognize that I often have to be dragged to miracles because I have a bad habit of either not recognizing or of arguing with my spiritual impressions. There was a time in the temple when I argued against a strong prompting several times. (There was a reason I was to be at the veil to assist a particular sister–this is one of those very sacred experiences I won’t share on a blog.) I am set apart to help with Spanish sessions, and I kept arguing that I wasn’t set apart to help at the veil with this session, which was an English one. I was in the Celestial Room to meet a woman being endowed in one of the sessions–I didn’t know which–and I was wearing my name tag identifying me as a worker. The internal conversation was like this: “Ask if you can help at the veil.” “No, I don’t think so.” “Come on, ask.” “No, I’m not set apart for this one. It’s English.” “Just ask.” “No, I’m not going to.” Finally, another worker crossed the room, passing every other worker, and came up to me. “Could you help at the veil?” she asked. I did, and there was a “striking” miracle (using DKL’s word). Obviously, I am stubborn. I wonder how many times I’ve won an argument I shouldn’t have won. DKL: You said: “One can say that it’s better to search for bread on the sabbath than for tobacco because it’s better to be Mormon. But I think that if you work out that line of reasoning, you’ll end up begging the question.” And thanks, DKL and Danithew for making me feel so welcome at MM. I do like MM. You’re a little premature in your invitation, though. You don’t really know me yet. The thing I like about MM is that I feel pretty free to say all sorts of things–probably because DKL has set that rather “in your face” standard. I enjoy that–even though I won’t be even slightly shy in meeting him squarely in the midst of his arguments and wrestling hard. I’ve already warned DKL that I have a rather wicked sense of humor. I could reveal it here, and you might be scrambling for a way to get me to quit blogging. Right now, I’m a nomadic blogger who does it between files of the footage I’m transcribing. I think I’ll stay nomadic for awhile. |
Speaking of moies that speak to miracles–a few years ago a film called “Millions” was released. One scene involved the appearance of St.Peter to a boy (modern day). Peter (the apostle) gives the boy an explanatiion of the miracle of the loaves and fishes. Basically what happened is that most of the 5000 had actually brought food along with them. When Jesus asked if any had any food to share everyone clammed up, except the small boy with the loaves and fishes. So Jesus, (being Jesus and sort of relising what’s goiung on) breaks up the loaves and fishes, places them in the 12(?) baskets and then passes them out to the crowd. As the baskets pass the people in the crowd–the ones too afraid to share their food– relise the error of their ways and keep for them selves only the food they need and place the left over amount in the basket. The result being all the surplus food and still everyone being fed. The point is that the miracle was that hearts were chnged not that food fantastically appeared out of thin air. Rent the movie–it is very good. cje |
If this same situation had occurred in ancient Palestine, might it not have been considered a miracle indeed if you could simply walk up the street and return a few moments later with a freshly-baked loaf of bread, wrapped in a clear preservative plastic bag, having not ground the wheat or baked it yourself? Who says there was no miracle? The problem is not that miracles no longer occur; but that the vast majority of us are blind to them. For you to have obtained the bread, so many things had to line up: you got in your car, or else the church just happened to be near a bakery or grocery store; the store just happened to be open on Sunday; the store was stocked with freshly-baked bread; you had money on you, at least enough to buy the bread you needed; there was no accident or mishap that inhibited your safe return to church; and you arrived a bit late for the meeting, but in plenty of time to have those appointed prepare and pass the bread as sacrament. There was a potentially serious problem: no bread for the sacrament. And yet, with such a miniscule (maybe a hundredth the size of a mustard seed?) amount of effort, in you walked witih a fresh loaf. No, the problem with miracles today is not that they do not occur; but that we look beyond them. It is a problem of a lack of vision, and a lack of interpretation. But then again, maybe I am the one over-interpreting. :-) Finally, I spiritedly disagree with your notion that you broke both “the Sabbath and the law.” For was not the Sabbath made for man, and not man for the Sabbath? Did Jesus break the Sabbath to heal? Did you break the Sabbath to provide bread? The literalism we often assume in Mormonism seems sorta childish at times. You needed bread for what you felt was an important and sacred rite; how can you say that you only obtained such bread by breaking the law? What if God made sure ahead of time that the store would be open and would have some fresh bread waiting for you as soon as you realized your folly in not following through with whomever was to provide the bread? Don’t assume He was not aware the whole time, and do not assume He did not actually in fact provide the bread for you. Yes, it’s all open to interpretation. I have no seer stones which give me the “real answer.” But neither does anyone else. Why, then, choose to interpret events in a way that undermines faith, when in actuality the problem was so easily solved? They say “God is in the details.” Maybe He is. |
Craig, I like your comment. I don’t agree with it, but I admire its ambition and scope. When we talk about miracles, are we talking about the ability to view anything at all (e.g., malaria or traffic signals) as extraordinary, or are we talking about a specific manifestation of divine agency that interrupts the natural flow of worldly occurrences? I tend to think that it’s the latter, but we may just have a difference in outlook. If you watch “The Price is Right,” you see the contestants jump up and down and scream when they win a coffee table. But on Jeopardy, they win thousands and evince no emotion at all. Though I don’t tend to view the world in general through the lens of game shows, I do tend to identify more closely with the Jeopardy-type reaction. cje, I’ve heard that before in the context of giving a naturalistic explanation for the miracle of the loaves. It sounds better in the context that you mention. Margaret, I think I may just have a hard time conceding that I’m any kind of manifestation of a miracle. |
cje, you forgot (?) to point out another thing Bloggernacle readers would find interesting about the movie ‘Millions;’ there is a pretty interesting portrayal of LDS missionaries in it as well. :-) |