36 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
Beautiful! |
Awesome! Next up: the poem “Boat Prints in the Sand.” |
I just re-read your post this morning, Brian. It’s perfect. It’s the best, most amazing post yet to be published in the bloggernacle. I read it to my wife, and she cried. She laughed, too, btw. |
This was lovely. |
I don’t know if I’ve used the church in the way Richard Dutcher describes it, or as you do. I don’t think it got me anywhere. My faith has occurred in spite of the many ways I’ve been disappointed–in the church, in my leaders, and in God. However, like you, I’ve had many friends abandon Mormonism. Friends who’ve faced depression, as I have; friends who’ve faced addiction, as I have; friends who’ve suffered from life’s capricious nature, as I have. I’ve chosen again and again to remain a Mormon. I think the word I’m looking for is dichotomy. I overlook the battered nature of religion in general, Mormonism in particular, the warts, the dings on the sides, and cling to a hope that what I’m being told is true. Once in a great while, the breeze is fresh and clean, and that old boat floats. I’ve read about women who leave the church and feel their lives are better, more peaceful and I wonder if that will work for me. I don’t have an answer or opinion. But, you know, Brian, if a Mormon artist feels they can better express themselves outside the church, how do they reconcile themselves to the loss of the basic plan of salvation? Do they pick and choose what they profess to believe–in the interest of artisitic freedom? How are they more free artistically outside the church? Do the more artistic among us become more sensitive to the incongruities of our beliefs and find themselves compelled to leave in the interest of truth? which actually is crap. The most striking thing I remember about you is your warmth and the depth of your faith as you talked to Sarah about her decision to go to the temple (she made it, by the way). You lifted my spirit that day. IF, and it’s a big if, we can bridge that gap between our ethereal, artistic natures with solid faith, as you have, the world and the church is a better place for it. I would respect Richard Dutcher so much more if he said, “you know, there are a lot of things about Mormonism that drive me crazy. But I believe.” instead of “I can’t express myself artistically while I’m a Mormon.” I don’t know, now I’m kind of bummed out. LOL, thanks, Brian. |
Brian, I love it. Thank you. |
Brian, Please sign me up for your fan club. This was so well done on so many levels. Great work. |
I’m speechless. Thank You! |
That was truly wonderful - very uplifting for a Monday morning at the old grind |
I keep my boat in the garage and only get it out on Sundays. To go waterskiing. |
Thank you. |
gorgeous. |
Beautiful post, Brian. |
That was awesome. Thanks, Brian. |
I’ve never liked the boat analogy, but I like the spirit of this post. |
context for those that are wondering |
The smile on my face when I thought about the matching ties almost killed me, it was so big. Sometimes I feel lucky, because I converted to the Church the year they were handing out ultra-light highspeed jetski hydro-foil land-phibian units (With a helicopter attachment). |
Darn converts, getting the cool boats. I was stuck in my dad’s boat until he kicked me out of it and told me to build my own. For a while, I was floating on a couple logs I lashed together. |
Masterful. Blows the “Parable of the Pickle” out of the water (no pun intended). |
Pithy and powerful. Thanks. |
My favorite line: Very funny. |
Best post ever, right next to MMW’s weird-mormon-stories. |
Wow. That is soooo cool. |
Okay, I wrote a book. The rest of you wrote short lovely (sometimes funny) comments. Did I miss something? |
annegb, Shhh! I’m still reading your last comment. |
j/k |
Bravo! |
[...] have been a couple of boat analogies kicking around the bloggernacle in the last few weeks. I don’t have a boat. I’m in an [...] |
Thank you for the kind thoughts, everyone. |
Thank you for this, Brian. |
Annegb, It was a lot of fun meeting your family that day. I’ve never had that much fun in an IHOP before, or was it a Village Inn? I can’t remember. But I bet those servers are probably still asking, who were those people? They were loud. You ask a lot of good questions about art and faith that I don’t have any answers to, and as reluctant as I am to lower your high opinion of me, I don’t know that my faith is that solid. I think a thin line separates faith and stubbornness much of the time. Maybe that’s something you and I have in common. Maybe when God was handing out Faith we were in the back of the line and by the time we got to the front they were scraping the bottom of the Faith Barrel and we said, what else have you got? Uh, we got some Stubbornness in the back. Yeah, okay, that’ll do, we’re in a hurry. I didn’t really write this as a critique of Richard Dutcher or his comments at By Common Consent. I just found the metaphor he used to express himself with to have both comic potential and a haunting quality. I take Richard Dutcher at his word that his decision to leave the Church behind had little or nothing to do with his filmmaking career. I have no special insight into his thoughts, of course, but as near as I can tell from what he’s said publically (which isn’t very near at all) he would have probably came to the same conclusions and choices if he were a plumber or an accountant. In other words, I think he was motivated more by maintaining personal integrity than artistic integrity. One thing’s for sure, I don’t have any magic way to bridge the gap between artistic devotion and religious devotion. For a lot of artists and storytellers there is no gap, but for some there is. More importantly, as far as Mormon art is concerned, some audience members are bothered if they perceive a gap, and others not so much. |
Well, I loved what you did with this boat analogy. Really beautiful. My favorite part is when you say you carry it because maybe someday you’ll come to a vast, deep ocean and need that boat. Isn’t that so true? My 7-year old daughter was whining about going to church. She yelled out at me, “but I already have a testimony… why do I have to go!?” I didn’t have a clean and clear and sensible response to her. But I think I’ll tell her about the boat. |
Thanks, Brian, I was totally without context. I hadn’t read Brother Dutcher’s post. After reading it, I feel differently. I think I understand Dutcher’s position. I was talking to my sister just the other day and sharing some things I’d learned about God and the nature of life. I made the offhand comment that I hadn’t learned them in church, that I’d probably learned them despite my membership. “The Church” confuses me. I’ve stayed a member but it seems we receive such conflicting messges about faith and Christianity and works that sometimes I’m not sure what I’m supposed to believe. That’s when I go back to The First Vision and the Plan of Salvation and take the rest of it on, uh. . .faith. Or maybe hope. |
Brian, I’m glad I’ve seen your boat before. Your boat and this post are inspiring. Thanks! |
My boat is bigger than your boat! |
[...] Gibson, whose “My Heavy Boat” post was nominated for Best [...] |