34 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
Devyn, This is one of my favorite posts in a long time. I rarely have spiritual experiences at Church; most of mine have occured outside of Church, and I love that you mentioned “on a mountain while hiking,” because that has been the context for me as well. I have wondered why, and I think a good, hard hike in the mountains can be a really humbling experience that opens you up to spiritual things. |
I was just going to head home and thought I’d check out MM before I did. Thank you for that lovely post, Devyn. (I’ll let Darius know it’s up also.) I have to admit that I have often fought against spiritual experiences. Sometimes I remember an impression well because I’ve fought so hard against it. I’ve had some amazing spiritual experiences in my lifetime, but I’d have to say that some of the sweetest have been the most subtle. When my best friend died and I went to the temple rather than to her viewing, I had one a profoundly moving moment at the veil–nothing miraculous, but a sudden reconceptualizing of what happens there, and the resurrection implied by the words we say. As I said them, I could see my friend rising from the dead. And what a miracle that I was able to speak at her funeral! I couldn’t speak at all for so long after she died. Bruce blessed me, and I was able to give the talk I had prepared–which I knew was exactly what she wanted me to say. (I had begged God to let me proxy for her and comfort her children; she had died suddenly and they were in such grief.) I also count it miraculous that one Sunday, when I was upset with my daughter for sluffing church and being rebellious, I was able to work past my own frustration and even past my own schedule. I took her to the Provo temple where we just talked. I always find it miraculous when, through the grace of God, I’m able to access a better part of myself than what wants to surface. |
The lack of information on the reasonings behind the Priesthood Ban was one major issue I faced before becoming a member. Brother Darius contacted me via email telling me:
Because of Three people who were not afraid to discuss this topic, I am now a member of the Church. And yes Mr. Gray I did take that trip to the Temple. I made it there with my wife, all three of my children, I even stood proxy for my Wive’s Father so she could be sealed to her parents. Thank You Margaret Young, Darius Gray, and much respect & admiration to the work of John Dehlin. Jamie Trwth |
Having heard Margaret and Darius talk I know where you are coming from. I’d guess that the subject matter (black experience/history w/ church), one that both pushes and challenges and possibly reframes previously held ideas, and yet reflects everything one comes to know about life/humanity (both the good and the bad), had something to do with your spiritual experience. My spiritual experiences usually have something to do with broadening or deepening my understanding, or experiencing unfiltered “truth”. That some of us do not often have spiritual experiences in Church (except, possibly, when music is involved) probably has something to do with the fact that sunday-meeting subject matter usually reflects a simplistic, or mythic, or idealistic, or sanitized worldview. The problem is that we are all at different stages in spiritual, or more important, emotional and intellectual development, and some people are at a stage in their lives where they do experience the spirit via a simplistic/mythic/idealistic frame of reference. Somehow, the poignant “untold story” of black Mormons doesn’t quite fit that worldview — too many rough edges, too many difficult and possibly unaswerable questions. It doesn’t conform to a tidy, all-is-well sunday school lesson. Which is too bad, because we often learn more about ourselves from our failures than we do from our victories. |
Spiritual experiences, I’ve learned, come in many different ways. One of the challenges of my life is found in having an abundance of spiritual experiences, like those found in the scriptures: dreams, visions, ministering of angels (so far unseen) and other manifestations of the Holy Ghost. The problem is that I am unable to talk to others about these things (my wife and a few close friends being exceptions. They believe me but can’t share in the same way. Some kind of problem, but one that is troubling nonetheless. I’m sure there are many others who share my trouble, but I have yet to meet them. I suppose others have learned, as I have, to keep things to themselves because it is no fun to be under wondering gazes of church members and loved ones. In recent years, I have attempted to talk more about these things. Blogs like this afford opportunities. Most all of my experiences have not occurred at church (with one noteable exception) but while in prayer or reading the scriptures. Then there are those experiences when I wake up in morning having received a dream from the Lord. On a few occasions my prayer for help dealing with a life issue have been answered as I wake up. It is like the room is filled with knowledge and I need to get a pen and paper and write my down my thoughts and feelings. I’m sharing this with the hope to increase faith of those who read it as well as hoping to find someone who feels and experiences the way I do. |
Dan E – thanks and I felt similarly in the MTC, but then on the mission there would be times when waves of emotion/spirituality hit you. That was one amazing two years. Margaret – thank you for the wonderful experience last week and for sharing more experiences here. Jamie – we are glad you are here. I think many have stumbled on that issue, but I am thankful you have been able to either set it aside or move past it for now. I wish I had that much faith to get past my stumbling blocks. Jared – I am usually at the opposite end of the spectrum – radio silence most of the time. I never thought about the challenges at the other end of the spectrum. Thanks for sharing your perspectives. Matt – that is a nice way to frame it and really speaks to how I feel about it. |
I have experienced many spiritual experiences at church particularly when singing the hymns. I have also had prophetic knowledge revealed to me in the temple, while vacuuming my living room, and during a bus trip accross town in Argentina. Most of the revelations so far have had to do with my children or my husband. There are dry spells to test my faith or because of my lack of it. Thanks for your post and to those who have responded. The blog brought to mind these spiritual experiences which is very pleasant indeed. Marcia |
I’m very excited about this documentary that Margaret and Darius are doing … can’t wait to see it. I like the title and the idea of spiritual experiences being a lottery – that you don’t always know when and where a spiritual experience is going to come to you. I once had a memorable spiritual experience while reading the Book of Mormon on a bus. I had been reading the Isaiah chapters in 2 Nephi and suddenly I hit chapter 25 and Nephi’s plain language just hit me over the head that day. By the way Margaret, I love the way you describe things and the words you choose. You really have such a gift, I think, for communicating. I loved reading your thoughts that you shared in comment #2 on this thread. |
For the record (seriously, since I don’t keep a journal): Suddenly, it all came together. I got the e-mail explainiing that someone had cancelled and asking if I could accept the invitation to speak at the conference. Darius was asked to address the NAACP. But he had just done an exhausting trip to NY and, since he has cancer and NO energy, a trip to Boston didn’t seem like the wisest choice. Darius made the call–after I had voiced serious concern: we’d go to Boston. Our flights were covered by the separate conferences we were attending, and I submitted my itinerary between various tasks–quickly realizing that I didn’t really need to be in Boston as long as I had scheduled myself; I could’ve returned home a day earlier. But of course, perhaps the most important meeting (not the fundraiser–sorry Devyn) was an impromptu one with some young African American Latter-day Saints, many of them new converts. It happened late on Sunday. So we were where we needed to be when we needed to be there. I was greatly preoccupied with family events; Darius was so ill that he had nearly collapsed a couple of times. But all of that had to be swept aside so we could do what we were being asked to do. For me, it was miraculous to see Darius rise to the occasion. I doubt anyone at any of the events we did knew how ill he was (and I believe he was given some additional strength or he could not have done a fraction of what he did). Part 2, however, is that though we had some marvelous experiences sharing our offerings with various groups, our own problems didn’t vanish just because we were doing good things. Once we were headed home, Darius was in great pain, and my mind returned to concerns over a family member. We had been renewed and magnified for the duration of the weekend, and perhaps were better able to face our challenges after such a spiritual baptism, but the cancer remained for Darius, and the things I had been concerned about at home were still a concern. Spiritual experiences are touchstones, but they don’t automatically change us. We seek places where we can remember what God has already given us and try to be aware of new miracles which become new touchstones and light our path (backwards and forwards). But the path is still very thorny and difficult. We negotiate it through faith, hope, and often calling on our courage to simply take the next step. |
Great post, Devyn. It was good to see you at the event. I think that Margaret Young’s documentary is going to be of historic importance. And Darius Gray is an amazing man. And the event was, indeed, a big win. |
Jared–I still have a letter written to me thirty years ago from the first love of my life: a beautiful Mexican boy I met when I lived at Benemerito (Mexico City). I have often thought that because my Spanish was so limited at the time, I was forced to use other ways of communication. (Don’t imagine anything unseemly, DKL.) Because I had been shielded by a facade of intellectualism (which I can still slip into, though I try not to), I hadn’t let myself be terribly vulnerable. But I couldn’t be an intellectual in Spanish. Anyway, the letter he wrote me was a response to my announcement that I was engaged to a Gringo. He told me he already knew, because he had had a dream where he saw “un hombre luminoso” (a shining, luminous man) who had asked him to follow. He saw me with a Gringo (white guy), and saw that there was another woman for him, a “morenita” (brown-skinned). The dream went on for a bit, and he understood some things awaiting him in the future. He was in the hospital suffering from Tuberculosis when this happened, and told the man in the bed next to him about the dream. The man said, “I’ve had visions too. But don’t tell anyone about this. They’ll think you’re crazy. Keep very quiet about it.” I’m certain there are men and women who feel somewhat burdened by this spiritual gift because cynicism is so easy. (And frankly, there are crazy people who have visions all the time, so some folks are wary.) But, as my long-lost love told me, “Now I know that the scriptures are true, the ones that say ‘your old men shall have visions and your young men shall have dreams.’ Because my mother was afraid that I would run off and marry this young man, she hid his mail from me, as best as I can gather, so I didn’t get it until I had been married for a year. I wrote back, but the letter was returned undeliverable. I wonder what has happened to him. Primitivo Santos Chavez. I have a fantasy that someday I’ll go through the Mexico City temple and hear his voice on the other side of the veil. I wonder if I’d even recognize it. |
Devyn et al, I don’t entirely understand why there is a spectrum that you referred to. But apparently there is. But I do know that I have a lot more years in my rear-view mirror than I have ahead of me and I don’t want to go before the Lord and be found as one who buried my talents because of the fear of men. For a little over a year I have been more open with my experiences. The response I have received is interesting—a spectrum—with BS on one end and adoration on the other. Both of these extremes cause me pain. My purpose in sharing my experiences is not to draw attention to myself. I recently discovered blogging and decided to use this as a means to draw attention to the fact that God is no respecter of persons and that each of us can draw closer to the Savior if we really desire to do so. 1. Whatever church calling we have and will magnify is adequate. I have never been in a high profile position. 2. With the knowledge contained in the 4th Article of Faith we can have the veil made thin. When we’re confirmed we’re commanded to receive the Holy Ghost. If we will focus on doing this everything else will fall into place. We must believe that the greatest objective in this life is acquiring the gift of the Holy Ghost and the attending gifts of the spirit. 3. Regarding worthiness. I have much more in common with Alma (both younger and older) than I do with Nephi. I’ve learned how to repent. I’ve gone to the throne of grace and boldly sought the Savior. I know by experience that what Elder Bednar said in this conference and last is true. It was not easily won but I wanted it more than anything else in this world. 4. Have faith that your prayers are heard. Don’t be afraid to put it all on the line and ask for what you need. Plead with the Lord to clearly and directly answer your prayers so that you will know the answer came from Him and not circumstances. Talk with Him. Get Gene R. Cooks “Receiving Answers to our Prayers†and pay particular attention to page 12-13. Jared |
Jared,
I have seen how people respond to your experiences; the thing you have to realize is, what you write looks like you are boasting. When you approach the blogs with the tone of “I have had so many spiritual experiences, and therefore I have so much to teach you people,” that is a huge turn-off to the rest of us. You come across as someone who wants to talk a lot about himself and dispense spiritual prescriptions for other people, and that just doesn’t work here or on any of the other blogs. There simply isn’t much of a market for what you are selling. |
#11 Margaret Thanks for sharing your experience. I saw what you had written after I posted #12. Writing for me is like scraping paint, a chore. But I enjoy what writing brings out of me. It allows me to feel anew experiences decades old. It also provides me the opportunity to see aspects of my life with fresh perspective because of viewing them through the lens of time. It’s like using Google Earth and going down to a street view and see details not observed before. I think it is wise to be wary of those who talk of dreams, visions, and etc. I have come across some in the church who use their claimed spiritual manifestations to gain “disciples†they can manipulate for their own purposes. In every case I have observed, these people are soon detected and shown the door via church court. But for every deceiver there must be hundreds and thousands who are true followers of Christ. I am in the process of setting up a blog with the purpose of helping those who visit to fulfill their baptismal covenant of receiving the Holy Ghost. I feel that I’ve just scratched the surface of the possibilities we as members of the church have. I’ll close with a thought from Elder Bruce R. McConkie: Men ought—above all things in this world—to seek for the guidance of the Holy Spirit. There is nothing as important as having the companionship of the Holy Ghost…There is no price too high, no labor too onerous, no struggle too severe, no sacrifice too great, if out of it all we receive and enjoy the gift of the Holy Ghost. |
#13 Dan, I understand your concern and I all can say is that my intent is different than your characterization. You see it from the BS side of the spectrum. Devyn said: “I would love to hear about others spiritual lottery wins.” I honestly responded. I’m sorry that you think I’m attempting to sell something. Sharing isn’t selling. Dan–unless someone here invites me to respond I won’t write again. I have no desire to cross swords with you on scared subjects. |
Jared, I think your own blog is a great idea. That way, if people are really interested in reading your spiritual insights or getting spiritual advice from you, they can go there. Blogs like this one and others in the bloggernacle tend to be more issue-oriented, and I think you would do better in a site primarily dedicated to you and your thinking. Best of luck. |
I didn’t think you were boasting at all, Jared. It didn’t even cross my mind till Dan brought it up. Sorry, Dan, I don’t agree with you. I wonder, Jared, are you surrounded by people who don’t share your interest or faith? I don’t mean non-LDS, I mean faith. I find myself unable to talk about a lot of my interests with my family, so blogging is that outlet for me. I’ve always wondered if people thought I was bragging when, I think it was on Times and Seasons, I said I could dimly understand Jesus’ pain in Gethsemane because sometimes when other people hurt, I hurt. Physically and emotionally. It’s miniscule compared to Gethsemane and I wasn’t bragging. But it probably sounded that way. I’ve had spiritual experiences, but not for a long time, maybe a few. I’ve seen the hand of God in my life, but I lost trust in Him and got really mad and am barely getting that back. But last Sunday, this woman I’ve visit taught, who has been through hell and part of it is hormonal and she sort of made a mess of herself and sobbed for days and got mad at everybody and overreacted to being released from a calling I would go jump off a cliff if I ever got called to–anyway, it was sort of public and drippy and stupid, like Ellen crying over the dog. And I just kept loving her and so did others and last Sunday she got up and bore her testimony. I can’t recall her ever bearing her testimony and it wasn’t eloquent, she was crying so hard she could hardly talk, but it was totally sincere and I was just filled with love for her and thanked God for sticking in there with her. And it was spiritual, not the usual crap. Margaret, I really really want to buy that tape. I admire you for all you’ve accomplished and envy your energy. You have no clue how you’ve been blessed that way. |
annegb, I see what you’re saying; Jared has visited other blogs asking if he can share his spiritual experiences with everybody, almost like he’s shopping some compelling story for everyone to read. I don’t that’s what Devyn was asking for; I think Jamie(#3)’s response is. As always, I could be wrong. |
The precept that I’ve heard from church leaders, local and GAs, is that you shouldn’t share spiritual experiences unless prompted of the Spirit to do so. I’ve started to talk less about spiritual promptings on my blog, and when I do mention them, I’m less descriptive and less analytical. Annegb: I think childhood trauma can sometimes make people empathic to others. Some victims of child abuse or other severe trauma in childhood become permanently “broken” or perpetual victimes; some go on to be victimizers/abusers; and some become compulsive fixers or helpers in order that others don’t suffer as they did; and some have degrees or phases of all three. I don’t think one necessarily needs to have been victimized or traumatized in order to understand the Atonement and the Lord’s suffering. But perhaps there are some of us who need that lesson. It brings up the question of why the innocent have to suffer so horribly. The closest answer I’ve found is that God has reasons to let bad things happen to innocent people, and there are more reasons than just agency. Those reasons have to be learned on one’s own because it would be very crushing for an individual to be told that God wanted him or her to suffer, without having first learned and accepted those reasons. I thought I posted a comment with links to a Mormon Testimonies site, and a Mormon Converts site. Did I have a senior moment and not post it, or was it deemed inappropriate? I think both of those sites have good accounts spritual experiences. |
Bookslinger, you’re right. I think the setting makes a difference, which is why I think the things Margaret shared are appropriate. It’s important for us to hear the the amazing experiences that have attended her and Darius’ work on this project, and I think Devyn’s experience watching the film is appropriate and important to share as well. But to approach strangers and ask to share sacred experiences, rather than allowing it to emerge naturally in a conversation among friends in the right setting- that doesn’t sit well with me. However, it seems to sit okay with annegb, so I say more power to her. I accept that I may be in the minority in feeling this way. |
#10 annegb- thanks for sharing your feelings #15 + 16 + 18 Dan- I consider your additional remarks an invitation to write again. Dan-I started blogging at the first of Aug this year. I’ve blogged in 5 or so sites for a total of approximately 15 or so post. My purpose in visiting these sites, was and is, to learn about blogging. I posted comments about the “things of the spirit†in response to a post or a comment. I never asked to share my spiritual experiences. I did ask what is required to be able to post an article. That may be what you are referring to. Do I have an agenda in mind? Yes, I would like to find a place where people appropriately discuss things of the spirit. I would like to learn and share with like minded members of the church. Isn’t that the purpose blogging? Why are you anxious to make it appear as though I am a blogging terrorist deserving of being tarred and feathered? Where is your spirit of inquiry and brotherly love? Bookslinger-your point is well taken and the reason I came to the world of blogging is because of being prompted to do so. So far I’ve found that LDS blogging is filled with a lot of great people. People with advanced degrees in all kinds of subjects However, the topics are often about finding fault with the church, and its policies. This is a surprise to me. And of course I’ve found that topics that have to do with the things of the spirit are off limits. So be it. I’m not trying to force my will on others. In fact, the opposite is what I’ve experienced; others are more than willing to force their wills on me. I’m worried that this generation of church members may be fulfilling what Moroni warned about in his last writings. Out of all the messages Moroni might have left us on the last pages of the Book of Mormon he felt impressed to leave this one: …if the day cometh that the power and gifts of God shall be done away among you, it shall be because of unbelief. And wo be unto the children of men if this be the case; for there shall be none that doeth good among you, no not one. For if there be one among you that doeth good, he shall work by the power and gifts of God. Moroni 10:24 – 25 If anyone is interested, I will leave my new blogging address if asked. I just set it up last week and will start blogging soon. It will be a lot different than you might expect from what you’ve seen here. I hope to provide resources for those who want to fulfill their baptismal covenant and receive the Holy Ghost as their companion. Jared |
Jared, Your comments definitely bring up a lot of valid questions about whether the Spirit, personal revelation, etc. are given short shrift in the bloggernacle. I imagine you and I think more alike than you know, when it comes to this issue. Do a post on that subject on your blog, and I’d love to come over and comment. |
Jared, Be sure to start the url with http:// And just once per blog that you visit, it’s usually okay to tack on a PS to your (on topic) comment, and in the PS announce that you just put up your own blog. Repeat: generally one “By the way, I’ve got a new blog” plug per visited blog. However, a comment containing _only_ the blog announcement may be tacky. When you put the link in all your comments (in the appropriate edit field), if people like your comments, they’ll hover the cursor over your name to see if you have a blog, then follow the link, to see what else you have to say. Another unwritten rule is: If you want to write a long dissertation on the subject matter that appears on someone else’s blog, then write your long dissertation as a post on your blog; then go to that other blog, enter a comment and a link to your dissertation at your blog. Such as: “I wrote a bit on this topic on my blog at: http://jaredsblog-or-whatever.blogspot.com/2007/10/what-I-think.html There are three blog lists that I know of to submit your new blog to: http://www.ldsblogs.org/ It’s also good to submit/list your blog at http://www.truthlaidbear.com/ And then the major search engines: It’s usually a good idea to build up your own content on your blog before you ask other bloggers to link to you. That way they can get a feel for what your blog is about. Good luck. |
Quick question: Did the spam filter delete my comment(s) or are they just held for moderation since they have links in them? |
Bookslinger, your comment got stuck in spam; I just recovered it. Thanks for the heads up. |
Dan, Your perception of my efforts at blogging need to be corrected. First, regarding frequency. I have no idea what is average for spiritual experiences. To my recollection, I’ve never mentioned anything about frequency in any blog. When I use the word abundance I’m not thinking in terms of frequency. I mean breadth. Second, I don’t have any desire to focus on my spiritual experiences in a blog. This is not about me (I beginning to see why you were put off with my comments). Please read #12 above to get a general idea of what I’m about. My purpose in talking about my experiences has been to try an open a discussion with others (not a lecture). Based on what I’ve experienced in the last few months I doubt I will mention much about my experiences in the blog I am starting. I can see that it is almost universally rejected. I had supposed that blogging would offer a venue to explore spiritual experience in a unique way because it could be done anonymously. I was wrong. Bookslinger-thanks for your help. I noticed that some of those who made comments were linked. It was on my to do list. Thanks for the hand up and advice. Jared |
Coming back to the topic at hand… I have rarely had a spiritual experience during the normal Church block. What I have found, however, is that many times Church can serve as a trigger or catalyst for an experience that will occur later. Someone might say something in church that leads me to a different thought while I’m studying the scripture, or off on my own hiking. Church meetings may remind me of something I should be doing better – like the sincerity of my prayers, or rendering service. These reminders then sometimes lead to spiritual experiences. I have also had the experience of learning or hearing something in Church that gives me perspective of an experience I had in the past, but didn’t recognize at the time. |
Jots G. Well said. I rarely have a spiritual moment at Church. In fact I find Church to be stressful. For me activity in the Church is an anchor to earth that allows me to soar spiritually once in awhile. Recently the most powerful spiritual experiences I have had have been during in the process and finally adoption of our youngest child. I have learned much and have been stretched in areas of God’s love, the big picture, patience, acceptance, and endurance. |
The general authorities, in their general conference talks, are usually very reserved in describing spriritual experiences, or promptings of the Spirit. President Monson is the only one that comes to mind who is blunt about describing promptings. And they all seem to couch their phrases |
Margaret – #9 That is the great part about spiritual experiences is that it buoys us up in times of trial. It sounds like the entire Boston trip was divinely arranged. Jared – thanks for your comments and thoughts. I wish I could have more spiritual experiences. It is likely my own internal stumbling blocks preventing me from more experiences, but, nonetheless, it is fairly random for me still. Jota and JABenson – thanks for the comments. I like the Church as the anchor comment. It certainly does that even if it can be hectic and stressful. I rarely listen much to Sacrament Meeting anymore as I am usually chasing a 2 year old around or trying to entertain him enough to prevent distracting those around me. Bookslinger – good insight. Why do you think that is? Those talks wherein they have talked of their own experiences are my favorites (e.g., Elder Haights dream). I would like more of that as those talks help my spirituality more than another lecture on pornography for example. Not to say the lectures on porn are not useful. |
Bookslinger, I think GA are more reserved about their experiences when there is a world wide audience as compared to other places like a stake conference, or a book. I read Elder Busche, “Yearning for the Living God”, last year. He shared many spiritual experiences that I don’t think he would have share anywhere else. I learned as much about Heavenly Father has I did about Elder Busche. Jared BTW You have a great website and a special way about you |
#28 I totally agree, church makes me a nervous wreck. And lots of times Bill and I come home feeling like crap and losers. This happened especially when the kids were little, we were poor, our marriage was cluttered with huge knock down fights and we just thought we sucked. I’d come home totally depressed. Not so much anymore now that the kids are gone, but I feel that perhaps I’m too mentally ill to get anything from church. No lie. Jared, I’d like to take a look at your blog. Daniel, is your concern that Jared is going to announce that he’s the prophet or the new Messiah? Because I see that as valid. We could check it out, though. |
Margaret: Can I say that I absolutely love the way that you love Darius Gray. It’s so potent and wonderful. Darius is a hero of mine, and in my prayers as he struggles on. |
[...] this a follow-up to Devyn’s fantastic post on The Lottery of Spiritual Experiences. In that post, Devyn refers to hiking in the mountains as a context for spiritual experiences, [...] |