20 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
This was difficult, but in the end, I would have her pick marching band. (By the way, I’m pretty sure it’s “sousaphone, as in John Philip Sousa.) |
Yeah, but Susan probably thinks of it privately as “Susa[n]phone.” I’d ride along with her to marching band, too. She seems like a good kid, and someone as determined as she is — that ol’ girl has a stubborn streak, but also a cooperative one — she’d probably be open to some kind of home seminary, or picking it up herself anyway. Funny, weird, yet somehow believable story, ESO, and a lot of fun to vote for an alternative. |
Thanks for the spelling advice, guys. Right on. |
My vote is for Sousaphone as well. (Maybe something predictably LDS will happen in marching band, like a chance to share the gospel, or she’ll meet her future husband. Or both?…) |
No, seminary is so important! If she misses a day she’ll lose her chances for eternal salvation! I can’t believe her parents are neglected their sacred duty to rear her in righteousness to even allow her to consider missing seminary. I guess that is what happens when people move away from Zion. |
If my only choices were marching band or seminary, I’d probably end it all. |
Seminary. I’d like to try to keep this realistic. Children raised outside Utah who don’t go to seminary tend to go inactive. (Yes, someone can bash me for being too true blue, but go ask every stake about the correlation between seminary and church activity. Plus, how else can Susan ever get admitted to BYU and finding her eternal spouse without seminary? :) ) But I’m going to bet that the sousaphone segment is already written. (And we skipped over three years of law school in 2 paragraphs?) |
Jim–I’m so glad you have had other choices! queuno–NOT written, my friend. I am really going by your votes. Sorry to disappoint on law school–not only do I have no personal experience of law school, but I have really intended this story to follow the daughter, not the parents, I just wanted your help naming her. |
Jim Donaldson FTW! |
Join the band and ditch seminary – can we vote on whether she goes apostate or not based on skipping seminary? |
Sousaphone – as long as it’s just the first semester of seminary she’s skipping. It’s not like she’s dropping out. Her parents can have her make up for it by regularly reading Especially for Mormons. |
Sousaphone. No value judgment here, it just seems that there are more dramatic possibilities there. Unless her seminary teacher turns out to be a sousaphone player. That could go some interesting places, too. Now I’m indifferent. |
band. This sounds more like truth than fiction. In which case her parents will force her to take seminary. |
In real life, we chose the sousaphone and missed all 4 years of seminary because Church education refused to allow home study. |
You know, it occurs to me that, as a kid, I was always more intent on discovering all the cool ways to die than on getting through to the happy ending… With that in mind I suppose that, from now on, I’ll have to vote for whatever seems most likely to send people down the path to spiritual death (or physical death, depending on the situation). |
Which is that, Orwell? Sousaphone or Seminary? Both paths seem like plausibly spiritual death trips. |
Yeah, I have no idea – it would depend on the school. Let’s go with Sousaphone, though, merely because high school band and / or choir trips are (often) orgies of sin. (Ever heard of a CTR? Choir Trip Romance?) |
Oh, yeah, and because if we’re looking at which is more physically dangerous, marching around in the streets would logically invite more opportunity for accidents than sitting in a classroom somewhere. |
Especially in a sousaphone. |
My vote is sousaphone. Then, find the correlation between no seminary and later inactivity – treat it as if it were odds of going inactive, roll the dice and abide by its result. |