13 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
In other news, if you want to find out anything about SLC anymore, you’ll be getting it from the Trib. At least Robert Kirby works for the Trib. |
[...] an LDS perspective, I’d suggest checking out this insider’s view of the new board: The Editorial Advisory Board looks to me like the starting lineup of a Mormon [...] |
I faithfully read the Deseret News nearly every day for many years, but in the age of the Internet there just isn’t much there that is worthwhile. Far more detailed national coverage is easily obtainable for free from any number of sources. Local news is the only reason I can think of why anyone would want to subscribe, and there just isn’t enough local news to justify a daily newspaper. That is why I predict that the Deseret News and nearly every other newspaper in the United States is going to go to a weekly format, with online updates. That is a paper I would subscribe to. As a daily, I don’t find it worth reading, even when the Deseret News is so desperate as to continue to deliver a couple of papers a week to my house for free, months after the former residents cancelled their subscription. |
SLC survived a long time with two papers that had different viewpoints. The problem with the Deseret News is that they stopped delivering news. |
Here is one possible problem. What if the DN cuts their original reporting efforts a great deal, ceding the “news” job to the Trib? There are a lot of people that discount everything that appears in the Trib and only believe the DN. So what happens to investigations into corruption or some of the oddball politics that have happened even over the last year? It will appear to many that the Trib is on a witch hunt because of the silence from the Mormon paper. Legitimate scandals may get passed over because of the dynamic we yave here. We need the DN to be a legitimate news paper, not a PR arm of the Chirch. |
It means the paper is going to be run by Mormon elite, who leave little room for dissenting opinions or actually anything outside of fluffy Mormon perspectives; I never buy that paper. If I buy a paper when traveling, etc., it’s always the Tribune. |
arJ – The news has already ceded this stuff to the Trib. Let’s say you’re someone with an interest in Utah news but consider yourself fairly open-minded and fair and balanced. Go compare the major stories from the last year in both the Trib and the News (full disclosure: I have both in my Google Reader feed). The News just doesn’t cut it. Peggy Stack so owns the News it’s not funny, when it comes to any news about the Church. (The Mormon Times has a guy named Joel Campbell who seems to report on references to the Church in the news, but he’s incredibly one-sided and hypersensitive.) The news about BYU and the MWC? You don’t get anything close to meaningful about of the News. Want to know about Utah State’s (bad) decision to stay with the WAC? Don’t read about it in the News (full disclosure: I have a brother-in-law who is a VP at USU, and whose accounts of their decision-making process I have used to decide that the Trib is a little more accurate). George P. Lee’s death? Not only did the News not even mention his excommunication, they edited comments that brought it up. No one who actually cares about the news in Utah will miss the News. If you want your Mormon News, you’re not reading the Trib anyway so you won’t notice. |
I will say, that I liked the News’ Reader feed best for national news from the AP, because they gave much more complete summaries and I didn’t have to click through to read it. Much better than the Dallas Morning News, for instance. But that’s about the only good thing I’d get from the Deseret News that was worthwhile. Harmon is good reading if you’re a complete BYU homer, but he’s so incredibly one-sided. Back when I was a student at BYU, I had an email exchange with him over the circus events that went on at a BYU-Utah game in which I had attended (the events took place right in front of me). I’m convinced he hasn’t attended a game in 2 decades and just watches on TV. |
OK, last thought and I’ll shut up for awhile — I’d be surprised if the DN has *any* penetration outside Utah. Most people I know in my stake get the Church News but may never have read the DN itself… |
The Deseret News used to be a good newspaper. But then it hired the former head of the Utah Republican Party to be its publisher. No advisory board int he world can make it a good, believable, unbiased newspaper again. |
I haven;t enjoyed the Dnews since the 90s. The reporting seems shoddy when compared to the Tribune, and even the Examiner sometimes. I’ll get my sanitized news straight from the blogs instead of paying for it thank you very much. |
As a Deseret News staffer, let me tell you, we are all waiting anxiously to see what happens. The dread in the newsroom is thick. The paper keeps hiring manager types (like the “new media leadership team”) who have Harvard MBAs and online business experience, but NO journalism experience, as a random John pointed out. Does not bode well for the “news” part of the newspaper. As for the other cracks about our news coverage, etc. — I’m sorry to say that I can only agree. Most of us regular staffers are sorely disappointed at management’s decisions, especially since John Hughes left as editor. We do have some great writers, but they can’t carry a paper alone. I’m a faithful Mormon, but management’s decisions to go “mo Mo” have driven me nuts. I just want my news straight up, please. And I really don’t need a blow-by-blow account of every LDS event that occurs, or “fluffy Mormon perspectives,” as annegb put it. I can only echo, from the well-put original post: “In any case, I am sad to see the Deseret News transforming itself from a local paper that reported the news (most of the news anyhow, there has been some filtering, but not much) to a Church-owned Mormon opinion and lifestyle operation, meant to serve Mormons and not the people of Utah.” Not exactly a victory for journalism. P.S. A random John, I have also subscribed to Newsweek for years, but when our subscription ran out a few months go, we didn’t renew either. |
Back in the early 80s the DN was actually a better newspaper than the Trib. Too bad. As for Newsweek, arghhh. |