38 Comments | leave a comment | RSS 2.0 for this post | trackback |
As long as the Trunk or Treat is not on Halloween itself I’m cool with it. |
This is the first year in nearly a decade that my ward doesn’t have a ward Halloween party on the calendar. I suspect the disappearance of the activities committee has something to do with it. I would be fine with having a ward Halloween party because I, too, like being with members of my ward, and I am fine with not having one because other activities that someone wanted to do are happening instead. |
I actually feel that it is inappropriate to celebrate Halloween in the church, particularly adding in gory/spooky decor and costumes. Trunk or treat makes sense if you live in an unsafe, spread out neighborhood, or Halloween falls on a Sunday and you want to replace it. But giving candy to the same kids who live on my block and will be getting candy from me 2 days later is silly. |
Mormons love Halloween!!! That’s a fact jack. Get used to it. I think it’s because Mormons are very kid and family oriented and are always looking for ways to do fun things with their kids. Halloween is great fun for kids and Mormons have embraced it for that reason. We have a lot of families in my ward that decorate their houses for Halloween with at least as much vigor as Christmas. It’s very big. enguinuity? I think you mean ingenuity. |
Just another example: My current bishop always decorates his house to the nines on Halloween and is always doing something crazy. Last year he dressed up like a scarcrow and sat on the front porch in a pose that looked like he was just a decoration. Then, when the kids got on the porch he would jump up and scare them. He almost made some adults pass out, and the kids screamed and ran like maniacs. Awesome. |
MCQ–ahhhh! I’ll blame it on my cold medicine haze. Thanks. I think you are right that Mormons just embrace it on the family fun level. Anita–I guess that makes a difference. Like I said, we won’t see people from our ward in our neighborhood. John Mansfield–good point on the activities committee. In this ward, it is something the youth host. I am fairly indifferent to it and if it disappears, I won’t mind. arj–good point! |
Our ward has done the Trunk or Treat for several years now. The only complaint I have heard has been the years when there hasn’t been anything else going on together with it, like a potluck, games, or something like that. In contrast, every year when the word gets out that Santa will be at the Christmas party, facebook posts are burning up about the pagan influence he brings. Go figure. |
I prefer to celebrate Halloween in the rich people neighborhoods. |
We had our ward Halloween party earlier this week. The kids loved it. We had a chili contest (which also served as dinner). We had a hot pepper eating contest. Members and non-members with kids all came. It was fun, and there was no other point. Doing something just for fun is fine, even in the Church, and even with scary costumes … |
We like Halloween parties because they are fun. Simple as that. Candy, costumes, celebrating. What’s not to like? I basically live in the Bible belt, so I’ve seen the “fall festival” “anti-Halloween” arguments in my evangelical neighbors (including freaky Jack Chick tracks about how those who celebrate Halloween are going to burn painfully in hell for eternity) and I’m unimpressed. |
As long as those nasty orange and black wrapped candies aren’t given out, I don’t care. Who buys those things, really? This year I tried to buy the full size candy bars to give out, but my wife cheaped out and has loaded up on dumdums…. sheesh. |
chris–it must be hard to live in a mixed marriage. |
All Hail trunk n treat for the reasons spelled out by MCQ. I also know evangelicals and the occassional Mormon who are opposed to Halloween. We need a new phrase like Bah candybah to describe these spoilsports. |
I live in the Bible Belt and recently had a stake president who banned Halloween in the stake for the duration of his reign. So, the wards had “Fall/Harvest/Cowboy Festivals” instead with no costumes. These usually included a chili/pie competition and face painting for the kids. The ward trunk-or-treat was always an underground, word of mouth affair held at a local school parking lot as we weren’t allowed to do it on church property. It was very different from the ward in Provo we had moved from where the tradition there was for the youth to throw a Halloween party for the Primary kids complete with games and costume contest. |
When I was a kid in the 60′s, we had a full blown, elaborate Halloween carnival for the primary kids involving the entire ward. It gave the adults and teens a chance to work together and the kids had alot of INNOCENT fun. I’ve never heard one Mormon I know object to Halloween. As for the Stake President who banned Halloween, it sounds kind of like the Administrator at the Assisted Living Facility I worked at a few years ago. He banned all alcohol for special events (such as Oktoberfest and New Year’s Eve) Because although he wasn’t LDS, he didn’t believe in drinking. Higher management had to remind him that he couldn’t impose his personal beliefs on the residents. |
When Trunk or Treat falls on a Saturday, make sure to show up at Church early so you can watch the primary children stumble into the chapel with their candy hangovers. |
So I read this article and I am truely interested in the entire trunk or treat thing but my issue lies with how the church gets the word out to its members and neighborhoods. I am not a member but come from a family that were some of the original pioneers. The church clames it creates a safe event for the kids and familys. What about the children that are not in the church and don’t get invited? What kind of message do you send them? This is the 5th and last year that my children have not been invited to it. How do you explain to your kids why they were not invited? I currently live in Utah County and I am so angry with how my children have been treated. You claim to be Christian based religion and you act just like the southern Baptists. Jesus loved everyone and seems like you do not promote that. Hopefully the next family that moves to your neighborhood and is not in your ward gets treated better then we were. Good bye Utah. |
Marcus- If I wasn’t a member of the Southern Baptist Church, I wouldn’t expect to be invited to their functions. If I wanted to participate, I would understand the responsibility lies with me to tell someone I would like to attend. I don’t know of anyone, in any church, that claims the gift of mind-reading. |
Yeah typical answer. I didn’t want to attend. My kids did. I thought you are supposed to promote your beliefs by being an example. I can see you are like the many in this state and fail terribly. It is people like you (living in zion) that causes the rest of the world (99.98%) to slam the door in the faces of your missionaries. I do respect those kids because they left the bubble and really are nice kids trying to promote their faith. Your “secret desires” comment is really childish and shows how out of touch with reality you really are. Guessing by your username you are living in Jerusalem? No? Didn’t think so. My best friend growing up as a child (LDS) warned me about Utah County as well as my family (LDS) in Idaho. I thought things would of changed but I can see they haven’t. You can say what you want about me I don’t care but making my kids feal bad about themselves is where I draw the line. They came with innocent minds but now they are Jaded. They believe in Christ but just not under the same roof. |
Marcus- Hmmmmm……so much I could say…….choosing not to. You should thank me. |
Marcus: Actually most wards do invite everyone in the ward boundaries, regardless of church affiliation, to social functions. My ward goes out of their way to do that by delivering flyers to every house in the ward boundaries every time we have any kind of social gathering, including Christmas parties, Halloween Trunk-or-treats or spook alleys, Bar-b-ques, etc. We have quite a few non-members in our area who attend. My guess is that the ward in your area just isn’t very good at getting the word out, but I’m certain your kids would have been very welcome to attend. LIZ, I’m not sure what your problem is, or what religion you actually belong to, but the Church I go to DOES invite non-members to its functions. It’s part of the reason we have social functions: to get to know our neighbors and invite them to spend time with us. You don’t need to be a mind reader to know that your neighbors might like to attend social gatherings, because it’s just normal human behavior and, as a bonus, it’s part of the gospel of Jesus Christ. Really. Look it up. |
MCQ; Marcus; I do want to say that not all fit the discription I have spoke about. I have seen many nice people here in Utah. I do not ask thier religion, just thank them for being nice. Seems like being nice is a vanishing quality now a days. |
My problem is with people who know perfectly well the church is run by volunteers who might have accidentally missed their house in delivering invitations. Especially when the person states they have LDS family and friends and live smack in the middle of Mormondom. It the whinny, victim-mentality that gets me. You want to know when the ward Halloween Party is? Walk next door to your Utah Mormon Neighbor’s House and ask. |
PS And the lesson I learned from Jesus is that he didn’t spend time with people who did not want to hear his message. Something about casting pearls before swine. If Mormons are so rude and mean, please go get your Tootsie Rolls from another church. |
“he didn’t spend time with people who did not want to hear his message.” actually, he did. |
He didn’t run away from them when they came at him, but no where does it say he sought them out. Big difference. |
To the troll: I am sorry your kids are not friends with the kids that invite their entire 3rd grade class to Sunday School. Must take after dad. |
[...] love crafts. The Halloween party may be one funnest things a Mormon ward does all year, despite the Trunk-or-Treat idea that has swept across all of Mormondom, and despite a handful of nay-sayers who think Mormons [...] |
NewlyHousewife; Living in Zion; I found this page because I was looking up the Trunk-or-treat thing here in Utah. I am sure and I hope Marcus was doing the same and stumbled across this website. |
If a non-member wants to go to a trunk or treat all they need to do is show up at the event. I have never heard of formal invites for these types of events. Its not like you need a ticket to attend. We have lots of non-members at ours all the time. I don’t think that there will be special assigned people who will be ejecting non-members from Provo county trunk or treats :) |
Maybe the comments here will get quoted in a future Conference talk about all our neighbors who want to come to church activities with us, but we didn’t invite them, and now they are discouraged. We’ll be taught to never leave our home for the ward meetinghouse without first checking if anyone else on our street wants to come too. |
#30 – Thank you, bbell for being a voice of reason. I am now the point of hysteria and can no longer be held responsible for my fingers on this topic. #29- Christopher – Thank you for being nice to missionary kids. Since I have a daughter currently on a mission in Oregon, it is nice to hear of your friendliness. I am sure as you get to know your neighbors well, (which in my experience takes about a year)you will find the people who appreciate your sense of fair play. I agree about the Welcome Wagon thing. Years ago I moved to a small rural town and I had a real life Welcome Wagon Lady come to my house with coupons from the local businesses and free samples of stuff. It was awesome and really helped me find my way around town. Haven’t ever heard of it again. Too bad, it was nice. |
Marcus- Why not just show up with your kids? I’m sure you would have been welcomed. Instead of holding a grudge, why not just tell one of your neighbors your kids were disappointed that they weren’t invited? I’m pretty sure you will get a formal invite to the next fun event the local ward sponsors. On another note, I ended up running out of candy during our ward trunk or treat this year. Fortunately, I had bags of marshmallows for a game that we didn’t end up playing. It was kind of fun to watch the shock on various faces as an entire bag of marshmallows was put into their treat bag. |
We’re in Seattle, and just hosted a big Trunk or Treat party on Saturday. We have dinner, games and activities throughout the church building, then trunk-or-treating out in the parking lot. It’s a lot of work, but we love it. One reason we count it a success is that it’s the one time of year we can actually get a whole bunch of different people here: the usuals, plus less-active families, inactive families, and lots of non-member friends and neighbors. We think about scaling it back sometimes, but we keep it up, because we know this is an activity that everybody feels comfortable inviting non-LDS friends to. It’s not a religious event – just a fun social event. Marcus – my heart goes out to you and your kids. It’s got to hurt to be surrounded by people who have a strong social network, and to feel excluded from it. We Mormons are generally really good at creating a tight-knit network among our ward members. We see each other at least weekly at church, and then we also visit each other’s homes throughout the month, and work together as volunteers in our church callings. We show up for baby showers , funerals, illnesses. We come together for baptisms, weddings, potlucks. We have lots of service projects – weeding, putting together hygiene kits, putting on a new roof for a widow, cleaning up litter at local parks, etc. We get to know each other through lots and lots and lots of activities – for a lot of us, church activity pretty much becomes our life. Personally, I really value that sense of community – it’s such a blessing to me to have this group of people that feels like an extended family. I really, really love my ward. But that sense of community doesn’t come cheap – it comes from investing lots of time with each other. And because we can get so busy with church activities, it doesn’t always leave as much time or energy for developing relationships outside of our ward, which is the negative side for somebody in your position. I’m wondering if you’re in a predominantly LDS area, and feeling out of the loop, if you could just try talking to some of your neighbors. Maybe you could just say something like, “Hey, my name’s Marcus. We’ve lived here a few years. We’re not LDS, and we’re finding it hard to integrate into the neighborhood. We want to make friends, but it seems like everybody around here does all their socializing through their church. We’re not really interesting in converting, but we’d love to be part of the social network. Would we be allowed to attend some of your ward social activities? We’d be happy to chip in. Maybe we could bring a dish to the next ward potluck, or come help you guys weed at the park, or pass out candy at next year’s Trunk or Treat? My kids are feeling left out, and we just want a chance to get to know people better.” I have a really hard time believing that any LDS congregation would reject that kind of offer. At least around here, we’d be thrilled to have you! We don’t really have a good mechanism in place for making sure that every resident of our ward’s geographical boundaries is aware of all of our social activities, but that’s not because we’re actively trying to exclude them. If I had a neighbor request to be included, I would definitely be very happy to keep them informed. So reach out, and see if you can’t figure out how to join in on some of the fun. I bet you’d be welcomed, especially if you arrived with a smile and seemed open to friendship. Good luck! |
Sounds like Marie made my point a lot more concisely than I did! |
Michelle, Marie, bbell, John Mansfield, and Living in Zion; Thank you for the good information and nice responses. I am gonna go out on a limb here and say Marcus is trying to reach out. Yeah he may sound jadded, but I do understand his frustration. I will say by posting on here might be his way of trying to figure out the best way to approach the situation. All the advice has not only helped him, but I am taking this and will try a better way to approach my nieghbors. As I stated before people’s religion doesn’t matter to me, I am now part of the community and want to be some active roll in it. Keep your head up Marcus and keep trying to find out what will work. Seems like for the most part, people here care about thier community. |
It had never occured to me that some wards (perhaps only in UT) would advertise activities to everyone in their ward boundaries, as MCQ has mentioned. That is nice. Of course, it is just not practiceable in most areas, where wards often cover a county or more. Our stake has a few big activities we actively advertise to the community: a Christmas concert, a charity run we host for a local shelter, etc. While we don’t advertise, our ward activities absolutely always have non-members in attendance because they were invited by someone in the ward. I hope Marcus and family will snag such an invite soon. Otherwise, just show up–people will be overjoyed to see you. |
Okay, back to the topic – although this reading has been interesting. I am a Primary President and do not want to be in charge of a potluck dinner, carnival, setting/up, etc. I’m not whining, I’m just wondering how any other wards divide up tasks, etc.? I’ve never done this before, but it sounds fun. Appreciate any input! I’ve never thought about specifically inviting neighbors. Fun! Now to get organized and actually do it!! |